Groenlund Catherine, Handal Boris
Former Lecturer, Faculty of Dentistry, The University of Sydney NSW, Australia.
J Contemp Dent Pract. 2013 May 1;14(3):501-10. doi: 10.5005/jp-journals-10024-1352.
This research project sought to explore the issue of what constitutes effective clinical teaching in the minds of both students and teachers.
As stakeholders of the dental clinical setting, teachers and students have valuable practical insights to share with the academic and professional community as to what constitutes effective dental teaching.
An explorative qualitative study of dental teachers' and students' perceptions of clinical teaching was carried out at the Faculty of Dentistry of Sydney University. Thirty-one clinical teachers and 12 students participated in this case study through an online questionnaire survey and a focus group, respectively. Responses were categorized in three major clusters, namely, instructional, curricular or organizational.
The findings reveal that both groups hold similar opinions on what constitutes effective clinical instruction including a shared passion for learning and teaching, being clear and organized, demonstrating clinical competencies as well as engaging in professional self-reflection. Most of the issues fell into the instructional cluster where establishing a positive relationship with students including providing constructive feedback at the clinical session came up as key factors contributing to the student experience.
There is a demand from both students and teachers to standardize clinical procedures and protocols as well as having a greater synchronization in time and content between lectures and clinical work.
本研究项目旨在探讨在学生和教师心目中,什么构成有效的临床教学这一问题。
作为牙科临床环境的利益相关者,教师和学生对于什么构成有效的牙科教学有着宝贵的实践见解,可以与学术和专业团体分享。
悉尼大学牙科学院对牙科教师和学生对临床教学的看法进行了一项探索性定性研究。31名临床教师和12名学生分别通过在线问卷调查和焦点小组参与了本案例研究。回答被分为三大类,即教学、课程或组织。
研究结果表明,两组对于什么构成有效的临床教学持有相似的观点,包括对学习和教学的共同热情、清晰有条理、展示临床能力以及进行专业自我反思。大多数问题属于教学类,其中与学生建立积极关系,包括在临床课程中提供建设性反馈,是影响学生体验的关键因素。
学生和教师都要求规范临床程序和方案,以及在讲座和临床工作之间在时间和内容上有更大的同步性。