Kontis D, Theochari I, Tsalta E
Unit for the Study of Cognition in Psychosis, Psychiatric Hospital of Attica, Athens.
Psychiatriki. 2013 Apr-Jun;24(2):132-44.
Dementia and bipolar disorder have been traditionally considered two separate clinical entities. However, recent preclinical and clinical data in elderly people suggest that they are in fact related. Several theories have been put forward to interpret their relationship which could be summed up as follows: (1) Dementia could increase the risk for the emergence of bipolar symptoms, or (2) conversely, bipolar disorder might be associated with heightened risk for developing pseudodementia or dementia. (3) Alternatively, dementia, other brain diseases or drugs affecting brain function could lead to the combination of symptoms of dementia and bipolar disorder in elderly individuals. The two disorders demonstrate similarities with respect to their clinical expression (agitation, psychotic, mood and cognitive symptoms) and structural brain neuroimaging (enlarged lateral ventricles and white matter hyperintensities using magnetic resonance imaging-MRI). Despite the above similarities, the two disorders also have important differences. As expected, cognitive symptoms prevail in dementia and mood symptoms in bipolar disorder. In dementia but not in bipolar disorder there is evidence that brain structural abnormalities are diffuse and hippocampal volumes are smaller. Dementia and bipolar disorder present different abnormalities in functional brain neuroimaging. The pattern of "ventral" hyperactivity and "dorsal" hypoactivity in brain emotional circuits at rest is revealed in bipolar disorder but not dementia. With respect to their treatment, acetylcholinesterase inhibitors and memantine are indicated against cognitive symptoms in dementia and also improve behavioural and psychological symptoms appearing during the course of dementia. Lithium, anticonvulsants, antipsychotics and antidepressants are effective in the management of the acute episodes of bipolar disorder of younger adults, but there are not yet evidence-based data in elderly bipolar patients. It is likely that the efficacy of anticonvulsants and antipsychotics is superior during acute bipolar episodes in elderly individuals, although both drug categories have been associated with important adverse effects. Current data suggest that the best option during the maintenance phase of the elderly bipolar disorder is the continuation of agents which have been shown effective in the management of acute episodes. The appropriate treatment of cognitive symptoms in elderly bipolar patients has not been thoroughly investigated. In addition, the therapeutic value of psychotropics except cholinesterase inhibitors and memantine in dementia is still controversial, due to their association with side effects. Recent studies which have focused on the role of lithium in dementia could help clarify the relationship of dementia and elderly bipolar disorder. Although there are promising findings with respect to the value of lithium treatment in the prevention of dementia, the existing clinical studies do not support any beneficial effect of lithium administration on enhancing cognitive functioning of people with dementia. The specific role of lithium in dementia and the preventive value of interventions against vascular risk factors in both disorders remain to be evaluated in future prospective studies.
痴呆症和双相情感障碍传统上被认为是两种不同的临床实体。然而,最近针对老年人的临床前和临床数据表明,它们实际上是相关的。已经提出了几种理论来解释它们之间的关系,总结如下:(1)痴呆症可能增加双相症状出现的风险,或者(2)相反,双相情感障碍可能与发展为假性痴呆或痴呆症的风险增加有关。(3)或者,痴呆症、其他脑部疾病或影响脑功能的药物可能导致老年个体出现痴呆症和双相情感障碍的症状组合。这两种疾病在临床表现(激动、精神病性、情绪和认知症状)和脑结构神经影像学(使用磁共振成像-MRI显示侧脑室扩大和白质高信号)方面具有相似性。尽管有上述相似之处,但这两种疾病也有重要差异。正如预期的那样,认知症状在痴呆症中占主导,而情绪症状在双相情感障碍中占主导。在痴呆症而非双相情感障碍中,有证据表明脑结构异常是弥漫性的,海马体积较小。痴呆症和双相情感障碍在脑功能神经影像学上呈现不同的异常。双相情感障碍而非痴呆症在静息状态下脑情感回路中表现出“腹侧”多动和“背侧’活动减退的模式。关于它们的治疗,乙酰胆碱酯酶抑制剂和美金刚用于治疗痴呆症的认知症状,也可改善痴呆症病程中出现的行为和心理症状。锂盐、抗惊厥药、抗精神病药和抗抑郁药对年轻成年人双相情感障碍的急性发作有效,但老年双相情感障碍患者尚无基于证据的数据。抗惊厥药和抗精神病药在老年个体双相情感障碍急性发作期间的疗效可能更好,尽管这两类药物都与重要的不良反应有关。目前的数据表明,老年双相情感障碍维持期的最佳选择是继续使用已证明对急性发作有效的药物。老年双相情感障碍患者认知症状的适当治疗尚未得到充分研究。此外,除胆碱酯酶抑制剂和美金刚外,精神药物在痴呆症中的治疗价值仍存在争议,因为它们与副作用有关。最近关注锂盐在痴呆症中作用的研究可能有助于阐明痴呆症与老年双相情感障碍的关系。尽管锂盐治疗在预防痴呆症方面有一些有前景的发现,但现有的临床研究不支持锂盐给药对改善痴呆症患者认知功能有任何有益作用。锂盐在痴呆症中的具体作用以及针对两种疾病中血管危险因素干预措施的预防价值仍有待未来的前瞻性研究评估。