Legum C, Shomrat R, Yedwab G, Jaffa A J, Rudick A
Isr J Med Sci. 1986 Mar-Apr;22(3-4):210-4.
A pilot project to detect neural tube defects (NTD) of the fetus by maternal serum alpha-fetoprotein (MSAFP) screening of women in early pregnancy was initiated in Tel Aviv in 1982 at the instigation of the Israel Ministry of Health. The program was designed to be an extension of routine pregnancy care, which in this city is provided in municipal family clinics that are attended by about 50% of pregnant women before the 20th week of pregnancy. Of these women, 89% complied with the program. Women with a MSAFP level above a cutoff point of 2.4 multiples of the median (MOM) were invited for an ultrasound examination of the fetus, without having to repeat the MSAFP test, thereby reducing maternal anxiety. This deviation from the usual test system protocol did not impair sensitivity (87%), or specificity of the test on its own (95.6%), or in combination with ultrasound examination of the fetus and alpha-fetoprotein and acetylcholinesterase testing of the amniotic fluid (99.9%). The program detected 13 fetuses with an NTD; there were two false-negative results and one false-positive. The predictive value of a positive test was 93%. Its effectiveness as a preventive measure was impaired by the fact that 50% of pregnant women did not attend the family clinic before the 20th gestational week. An educational program for professionals and for the public is contemplated in order to reduce this proportion. Only 50% of normal twin pregnancies had an elevated MSAFP. A check on compliance with other screening systems during the interview for MSAFP screening led to the detection and elective abortion of two fetuses with Tay-Sachs disease. MSAFP screening in Israel is cost-effective rather than cost-beneficial.
1982年,在以色列卫生部的倡导下,特拉维夫启动了一个试点项目,通过对孕早期妇女进行母血清甲胎蛋白(MSAFP)筛查来检测胎儿神经管缺陷(NTD)。该项目旨在作为常规孕期护理的延伸,在这个城市,常规孕期护理由市立家庭诊所提供,约50%的孕妇在怀孕20周前会前往这些诊所就诊。在这些妇女中,89%遵守了该项目。母血清甲胎蛋白水平高于中位数的2.4倍(MOM)这一临界值的妇女被邀请进行胎儿超声检查,无需重复母血清甲胎蛋白检测,从而减轻了母亲的焦虑。这种与通常检测系统方案的偏差并未损害检测的敏感性(87%)、单独检测的特异性(95.6%),或与胎儿超声检查以及羊水甲胎蛋白和乙酰胆碱酯酶检测相结合时的特异性(99.9%)。该项目检测出13例患有神经管缺陷的胎儿;有2例假阴性结果和1例假阳性结果。阳性检测的预测值为93%。由于50%的孕妇在妊娠20周前未前往家庭诊所就诊,其作为预防措施的有效性受到了影响。正在考虑为专业人员和公众开展一项教育项目,以降低这一比例。只有50%的正常双胎妊娠母血清甲胎蛋白水平升高。在进行母血清甲胎蛋白筛查访谈时,对其他筛查系统的依从性进行检查,结果发现并选择性流产了2例患有泰 - 萨克斯病的胎儿。以色列的母血清甲胎蛋白筛查具有成本效益而非成本效益优势。