Department of Engineering Science, University of Oxford, Oxford, OX1 3PJ, UK.
Department of Engineering Science, University of Oxford, Oxford, OX1 3PJ, UK.
Sci Total Environ. 2014 Aug 1;488-489:505-11. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2013.10.112. Epub 2013 Nov 25.
In this paper we show how the process analysis method (PAM) can be applied to assess the sustainability of options to mitigate arsenic in drinking water in rural India. Stakeholder perspectives, gathered from a fieldwork survey of 933 households in West Bengal in 2012 played a significant role in this assessment. This research found that the 'most important' issues as specified by the technology users are cost, trust, distance from their home to the clean water source (an indicator of convenience), and understanding the health effects of arsenic. We show that utilisation of a technology is related to levels of trust and confidence in a community, making use of a composite trust-confidence indicator. Measures to improve trust between community and organisers of mitigation projects, and to raise confidence in technology and also in fair costing, would help to promote successful deployment of appropriate technology. Attitudes to cost revealed in the surveys are related to the low value placed on arsenic-free water, as also found by other investigators, consistent with a lack of public awareness about the arsenic problem. It is suggested that increased awareness might change attitudes to arsenic-rich waste and its disposal protocols. This waste is often currently discarded in an uncontrolled manner in the local environment, giving rise to the possibility of point-source recontamination.
在本文中,我们展示了如何应用过程分析方法(PAM)来评估缓解印度农村地区饮用水砷问题的各种方案的可持续性。2012 年,我们对西孟加拉邦的 933 户家庭进行了实地调查,调查中收集到的利益相关者观点在这项评估中发挥了重要作用。研究发现,正如技术使用者所指定的那样,“最重要”的问题是成本、信任、从家到清洁水源的距离(便利性指标)以及对砷健康影响的了解。我们表明,技术的利用与社区的信任和信心水平有关,我们利用了一个综合信任-信心指标。改善社区与缓解项目组织者之间的信任措施,并提高对技术和公平成本的信心,将有助于促进适当技术的成功部署。调查中揭示的对成本的态度与对无砷水的低价值有关,这与其他研究人员的发现一致,表明公众对砷问题缺乏认识。有人认为,提高认识可能会改变人们对富含砷的废物及其处置方案的态度。目前,这种废物通常在当地环境中以不受控制的方式丢弃,从而有可能造成点源再次污染。