Suppr超能文献

热拉尔·德·奈瓦尔的疯狂

The madness of Gerard de Nerval.

作者信息

Beveridge Allan

出版信息

Med Humanit. 2014 Jun;40(1):38-43. doi: 10.1136/medhum-2013-010445. Epub 2013 Nov 27.

Abstract

This paper examines the madness of Gerard de Nerval, the nineteenth-century French writer. It looks at his account of mental disturbance, how he responded to the psychiatric profession and how he reacted to being diagnosed as insane. It considers his autobiographical novella of madness, Aurelia, which he began at the suggestion of his alienist, Dr Emile Blanche, and while he was still an asylum inmate. Nerval's story raises important questions about the nature of madness. Is it, as he contended, a mystical experience revealing truths about spiritual worlds inaccessible to the 'sane'? Does psychiatry fail to understand it and inappropriately reduce it to the categories of scientific reason? Or are such notions of the spiritual value of madness guilty of the charge that they romanticise insanity? Do they make extravagant claims for an experience that is often disturbing and debilitating? What is the relationship between madness and recovery? Should an individual try to forget their experience of mental disturbance once they recover, or should they examine what the event reveals about themselves? Can the language of madness be decoded to unveil profound truths as Carl Jung and R.D. Laing have suggested, or is it, as the psychiatrist German Berrios maintains, merely a series of 'empty speech acts', signifying nothing? And finally, how does one avoid writing about madness, and instead write madness?

摘要

本文探讨了19世纪法国作家热拉尔·德·奈瓦尔的精神错乱状况。它审视了他对精神障碍的描述、他对精神病学专业的反应以及他对被诊断为精神错乱的反应。文章还考量了他在精神病医生埃米尔·布兰奇博士的建议下、且当时仍在精神病院住院期间开始创作的关于精神错乱的自传体中篇小说《奥蕾莉亚》。奈瓦尔的故事引发了关于精神错乱本质的重要问题。精神错乱是否如他所主张的那样,是一种神秘体验,揭示了“正常人”无法触及的精神世界的真相?精神病学是否未能理解它,并不适当地将其简化为科学理性的范畴?或者,这种关于精神错乱的精神价值的观念是否犯了将精神错乱浪漫化的指责?它们是否对一种常常令人不安且使人衰弱的体验提出了过分的主张?精神错乱与康复之间的关系是什么?一个人康复后应该试图忘记他们的精神障碍经历,还是应该审视这一事件揭示了自己的什么?正如卡尔·荣格和R.D. 莱茵所暗示的那样,精神错乱的语言能否被解码以揭示深刻的真相,或者,正如精神病学家赫尔曼·贝里奥斯所坚持的那样,它仅仅是一系列“空洞的言语行为”,毫无意义?最后,一个人如何避免书写精神错乱,而是书写出精神错乱的状态?

文献检索

告别复杂PubMed语法,用中文像聊天一样搜索,搜遍4000万医学文献。AI智能推荐,让科研检索更轻松。

立即免费搜索

文件翻译

保留排版,准确专业,支持PDF/Word/PPT等文件格式,支持 12+语言互译。

免费翻译文档

深度研究

AI帮你快速写综述,25分钟生成高质量综述,智能提取关键信息,辅助科研写作。

立即免费体验