Colosio Alban, Soyer Philippe, Rousset Pascal, Barbe Coralie, Nguyen Francis, Bouché Olivier, Hoeffel Christine
Department of Radiology, Hôpital Robert Debré, Avenue du Général Koenig, Cedex, France.
J Magn Reson Imaging. 2014 Aug;40(2):306-13. doi: 10.1002/jmri.24366. Epub 2013 Oct 31.
To prospectively assess the added value of gadolinium-enhanced and diffusion-weighted (DWI) MRI for the diagnosis of pelvic recurrence from colorectal cancer (CRC).
Fifty-two patients with suspected pelvic recurrence from CRC underwent pelvic MRI with T2-weighted ("T2"), gadolinium-enhanced fat-suppressed T1-weighted ("gadolinium") and DWI MR sequences. Three readers (senior radiologist: R1, two residents: R2, R3) scored the likelihood of recurrence on "T2," "T2 + DWI," and "T2 + Gadolinium."
Twenty-seven patients had 42 sites of pelvic recurrence. On "T2," R1 achieved AUC of .95, sensitivity 88.4%, specificity 95.2%. For R2, these figures were .89, 81.4%, 90.5%, for R3 .90, 83.7%, 76%. Both Gadolinium injection and DWI significantly improved AUCs for residents but not for the senior radiologist: up to .988 (R2, P = 0.006) and to .98 (R3, P = 0.01) with DWI and to .96 (R2, P = 0.04), .98 (R3, P = 0.01) after gadolinium. All readers achieved slightly better AUCs with "T2 + DWI" than with "T2+Gadolinium" but not significantly (P = 0.68, P = 0.11, P = 0.3; respectively).
For diagnosis of pelvic recurrence from CRC, both DWI and gadolinium-enhanced MRI significantly increase diagnostic performances compared with "T2" MRI for residents. DWI may be helpful in patients with contra-indications to intravenous administration of gadolinium.
前瞻性评估钆增强和扩散加权(DWI)磁共振成像(MRI)在诊断结直肠癌(CRC)盆腔复发中的附加价值。
52例疑似CRC盆腔复发的患者接受了盆腔MRI检查,包括T2加权(“T2”)、钆增强脂肪抑制T1加权(“钆”)和DWI MR序列。三位阅片者(资深放射科医生:R1,两位住院医师:R2、R3)对“T2”、“T2 + DWI”和“T2 + 钆”序列上复发的可能性进行评分。
27例患者有42个盆腔复发部位。在“T2”序列上,R1的曲线下面积(AUC)为0.95,灵敏度为88.4%,特异度为95.2%。对于R2,这些数字分别为0.89、81.4%、90.5%,对于R3为0.90、83.7%、76%。钆注射和DWI均显著提高了住院医师的AUC,但对资深放射科医生没有显著影响:DWI使AUC提高至0.988(R2,P = 0.006)和0.98(R3,P = 0.01),钆注射后使AUC提高至0.96(R2,P = 0.04)、0.98(R3,P = 0.01)。所有阅片者在“T2 + DWI”序列上的AUC略高于“T2 + 钆”序列,但差异无统计学意义(P分别为0.68、0.11、0.3)。
对于CRC盆腔复发的诊断,与“T2”MRI相比,DWI和钆增强MRI均显著提高了住院医师的诊断效能。DWI可能对有钆静脉注射禁忌证的患者有帮助。