Berg Matthew J, Sorensen Christopher M
J Opt Soc Am A Opt Image Sci Vis. 2013 Oct 1;30(10):1947-55. doi: 10.1364/JOSAA.30.001947.
This work uses the discrete dipole approximation (DDA) to examine the internal electric field within a simulated carbon soot fractal aggregate in fixed and random orientations. For fixed orientations, deviations of the internal field magnitude up to ±50% from that assumed by the Rayleigh-Debye-Gans Approximation (RDGA) are found. Given the refractive index of the aggregate monomers and conditions for the validity of the approximation, such large deviations are no surprise. Yet despite this deviation, the far-field scattered intensity from such aggregates agrees surprisingly well with that described by the RDGA. Moreover, if the average over an ensemble of many random aggregate-orientations is calculated, both the DDA and RDGA scattered intensities obey the well-known power-law functionality in terms of the scattering wave vector and show a forward-angle intensity-maximum proportional to the square of the number of monomers. The explanation for this lies in the over and under estimations made by the approximation of the internal field, which apparently mostly cancel upon integration to yield the scattered intensity. It is shown that this error cancellation is related to the fractal structure of the aggregate and that the agreement between the DDA and RDGA improves with aggregates of increasing size provided the fractal dimension is less than two. Overall, the analysis suggests that both the special fractal character of the aggregate and its orientational averaging is important to account for the experimentally observed validity of the RDGA despite its poor description of the internal fields.
本研究采用离散偶极子近似法(DDA),研究了固定和随机取向的模拟碳烟分形聚集体内部的电场。对于固定取向,发现内部场强相对于瑞利-德拜-甘斯近似法(RDGA)所假设的值偏差高达±50%。考虑到聚集体单体的折射率以及该近似法的有效性条件,出现如此大的偏差并不奇怪。然而,尽管存在这种偏差,此类聚集体的远场散射强度却与RDGA所描述的惊人地吻合。此外,如果计算许多随机聚集体取向的集合平均值,DDA和RDGA的散射强度在散射波矢方面均遵循众所周知的幂律函数关系,并且在前向角处强度最大值与单体数量的平方成正比。对此的解释在于内部场近似所产生的高估和低估,在积分得到散射强度时,这些高估和低估显然大多相互抵消。结果表明,这种误差抵消与聚集体的分形结构有关,并且只要分形维数小于2,随着聚集体尺寸的增加,DDA和RDGA之间的一致性会提高。总体而言,分析表明,尽管RDGA对内部场的描述不佳,但聚集体的特殊分形特征及其取向平均对于解释实验观察到的RDGA的有效性很重要。