Wu Fang, Lu Guo-ping, Lu Zhu-jin, Wu Jing-lei, Li Zhen, Hong Jian-guo, Zhang Ling-en
Department of Pediatrics, First People's Hospital Affiliated to Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai.
Email:
Zhonghua Er Ke Za Zhi. 2013 Sep;51(9):649-53.
Practice recommendations have evolved, and consensus now exists among leading organizations such as the American College of Critical Care Medicine (ACCM) and Surviving Sepsis Campaign that fluid infusion is best initiated with boluses of 20 ml/kg, commonly requires 40-60 ml/kg but can be as much as 200 ml/kg if the liver is not enlarged and/or rales are not heard. The present study aimed to investigate and compare the changes of the hemodynamics and extravascular lung water after higher volume fluid resuscitation in a piglet model of endotoxic shock.
Twenty piglets were used for establishing animal models of endotoxic shock by intravenous infusing lipopolysaccharide (LPS). The experimental animals were divided into three groups according to the volume infused during the resuscitation. The three groups received different volume of saline in less than an hour after endotoxic shock. By the PiCCO plus system, we investigated the changes of hemodynamics and extravascular lung water.
After fluid resuscitation, global end diastolic volume inder, (GEDI) and intrathoracic blood volume index, (ITBI) markedly increased in the group of 80 ml/kg and 120 ml/kg, but there was no change in the group of 40 ml/kg. GEDI: Fifteen min after fluid resuscitation R1 was (261 ± 64) ml/m(2), R2 (457 ± 124) ml/m(2), R3 (413 ± 148) ml/m(2), 4 h R1 (251 ± 68) ml/m(2), R2 (422 ± 70) ml/m(2), R3 (470 ± 160) ml/m(2); ITBI: Fifteen min after fluid resuscitation R1 was (335 ± 69) ml/m(2), R2 (550 ± 179) ml/m(2), R3 (520 ± 183) ml/m(2), 4 h R1 (314 ± 84) ml/m(2), R2 (534 ± 96) ml/m(2), R3 (594 ± 200) ml/m(2) (R1 vs. R2 vs. R3, F = 26.373, P < 0.05; R1 vs. R2, R1 vs. R3, P < 0.05; R2 vs. R3, P > 0.05). CI of all three groups significantly decreased when the models were established. After fluid resuscitation, the base level was maintained in the group of 80 ml/kg and 120 ml/kg, but it was under the basic level in the group of 40 ml/kg.Fifteen min after fluid resuscitation R1 was (4.5 ± 0.7) L/(min·m(2)), R2 (6.4 ± 2.2) L/(min·m(2)), R3 (5.5 ± 0.7) L/(min·m(2)), 4 h R1 (4.1 ± 1.0) L/(min·m(2)), R2 (5.2 ± 0.9) L/(min·m(2)), R3 (5.1 ± 0.8) L/(min·m(2)). There was no significant difference in CI between these two groups (P > 0.05).ELWI of the group of 80 ml/kg and 120 ml/kg were still higher than that of the group of 40 ml/kg, 15 min after fluid resuscitation R1 was (19.2 ± 8.6) ml/kg, R2 (29.2 ± 5.5) ml/kg, R3 (23.4 ± 8.2) ml/kg, 4 h R1 (18.3 ± 6.5) ml/kg, R2 (23.8 ± 2.6) ml/kg, R3 (21.4 ± 3.9) ml/kg, but there was no significant difference in ELWI among the groups (P > 0.05).
Resuscitation with higher volume of fluid infusion in the early stage of endotoxic shock was more efficient to increase the preload and maintain the cardiac output at the baseline level, and might reduce the need for vasoactive agents. Meanwhile, resuscitation with higher volume of fluid in the early stage of endotoxic shock did not sharply increase the extravascular lung water.
实践建议已经演变,目前美国重症医学学会(ACCM)和拯救脓毒症运动等主要组织达成共识,即液体输注最好以20 ml/kg的推注开始,通常需要40 - 60 ml/kg,但如果肝脏未肿大和/或未闻及啰音,可达200 ml/kg。本研究旨在调查和比较内毒素休克仔猪模型中高容量液体复苏后血流动力学和血管外肺水的变化。
20只仔猪用于通过静脉输注脂多糖(LPS)建立内毒素休克动物模型。根据复苏期间输注的容量将实验动物分为三组。三组在内毒素休克后不到1小时内接受不同容量的生理盐水。通过PiCCO plus系统,我们研究了血流动力学和血管外肺水的变化。
液体复苏后,80 ml/kg组和120 ml/kg组的全心舒张末期容积指数(GEDI)和胸腔内血容量指数(ITBI)显著增加,但40 ml/kg组无变化。GEDI:液体复苏后15分钟,R1为(261±64)ml/m²,R2为(457±124)ml/m²,R3为(413±148)ml/m²,4小时时R1为(251±68)ml/m²,R2为(422±70)ml/m²,R3为(470±160)ml/m²;ITBI:液体复苏后15分钟,R1为(335±69)ml/m²,R2为(550±179)ml/m²,R3为(520±183)ml/m²,4小时时R1为(314±84)ml/m²,R2为(534±96)ml/m²,R3为(594±200)ml/m²(R1 vs. R2 vs. R3,F = 26.373,P < 0.05;R1 vs. R2,R1 vs. R3,P < 0.05;R2 vs. R3,P > 0.05)。建立模型时,三组的心脏指数(CI)均显著降低。液体复苏后,80 ml/kg组和120 ml/kg组维持在基础水平,但40 ml/kg组低于基础水平。液体复苏后15分钟,R1为(4.5±0.7)L/(min·m²),R2为(6.4±2.2)L/(min·m²),R3为(5.5±0.7)L/(min·m²),4小时时R1为(4.1±1.0)L/(min·m²),R2为(5.2±0.9)L/(min·m²),R3为(5.1±0.8)L/(min·m²)。这两组之间的CI无显著差异(P > 0.05)。80 ml/kg组和120 ml/kg组的血管外肺水指数(ELWI)在液体复苏后15分钟仍高于40 ml/kg组,R1为(19.2±8.6)ml/kg,R2为(29.2±5.5)ml/kg,R3为(23.4±8.2)ml/kg,4小时时R1为(18.3±6.5)ml/kg,R2为(23.8±2.6)ml/kg,R3为(21.4±3.9)ml/kg,但各组之间的ELWI无显著差异(P > 0.05)。
内毒素休克早期高容量液体复苏更有效地增加前负荷并将心输出量维持在基线水平,可能减少血管活性药物的使用。同时,内毒素休克早期高容量液体复苏不会急剧增加血管外肺水。