Block of sodium channels in planar lipid bilayers by guanidium toxins and calcium. Are the mechanisms of voltage dependence the same?

The block of single, batrachotoxin-activated sodium channels by saxitoxin (STX), tetrodotoxin (TTX), and Ca2+ has been investigated in planar bilayers. All three substances block in a voltage-dependent manner with hyperpolarizing potentials favoring block. Extracellular Ca2+ competitively inhibits binding of STX and relieves STX block. Trimethyloxonium, a carboxyl-methylating agent, eliminates block by STX and TTX and dramatically reduces block by Ca2+. These results suggest that STX, TTX, and Ca2+ compete for a negative site on the outside of the channel. The voltage dependence of block by STX (divalent cation) and TTX (monovalent) was similar (40 mV/e-fold), suggesting that voltage dependence is due to a conformational change in the channel rather than to the toxins entering the membrane electric field to block. A physical model, with an external binding site for toxins and Ca2+ and another site deeper within the electric field (associated with the "selectivity filter") that is accessible to Ca2+ but not toxins, predicts voltage-dependence Ca2+ block without invoking the conformational change needed to explain the voltage dependence of block by TTX and STX.