Division of Proteomics, School of Biotechnology, Albanova University Center, KTH - Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden.
Biotechnol J. 2014 Mar;9(3):435-45. doi: 10.1002/biot.201300341. Epub 2014 Jan 29.
An important concern for the use of antibodies in various applications, such as western blot (WB) or immunohistochemistry (IHC), is specificity. This calls for systematic validations using well-designed conditions. Here, we have analyzed 13 000 antibodies using western blot with lysates from human cell lines, tissues, and plasma. Standardized stratification showed that 45% of the antibodies yielded supportive staining, and the rest either no staining (12%) or protein bands of wrong size (43%). A comparative study of WB and IHC showed that the performance of antibodies is application-specific, although a correlation between no WB staining and weak IHC staining could be seen. To investigate the influence of protein abundance on the apparent specificity of the antibody, new WB analyses were performed for 1369 genes that gave unsupportive WBs in the initial screening using cell lysates with overexpressed full-length proteins. Then, more than 82% of the antibodies yielded a specific band corresponding to the full-length protein. Hence, the vast majority of the antibodies (90%) used in this study specifically recognize the target protein when present at sufficiently high levels. This demonstrates the context- and application-dependence of antibody validation and emphasizes that caution is needed when annotating binding reagents as specific or cross-reactive. WB is one of the most commonly used methods for validation of antibodies. Our data implicate that solely using one platform for antibody validation might give misleading information and therefore at least one additional method should be used to verify the achieved data.
抗体在各种应用中的使用(例如 Western blot [WB] 或免疫组织化学 [IHC])的一个重要关注点是特异性。这需要使用精心设计的条件进行系统验证。在这里,我们使用来自人类细胞系、组织和血浆的裂解物进行了 Western blot 分析,共分析了 13000 种抗体。标准化分层显示,45%的抗体产生了支持性染色,其余的抗体要么没有染色(12%),要么蛋白条带大小错误(43%)。WB 和 IHC 的比较研究表明,抗体的性能是特定于应用的,尽管可以看到 WB 无染色与 IHC 染色较弱之间存在相关性。为了研究蛋白丰度对抗体表观特异性的影响,我们对在初始筛选中使用细胞裂解物进行 WB 分析时未得到支持的 1369 个基因进行了新的 WB 分析,这些基因使用的是过表达全长蛋白。然后,超过 82%的抗体产生了与全长蛋白相对应的特异性条带。因此,在这项研究中使用的绝大多数抗体(90%)在目标蛋白存在于足够高的水平时特异性地识别该蛋白。这证明了抗体验证的上下文和应用依赖性,并强调在将结合试剂注释为特异性或交叉反应性时需要谨慎。WB 是验证抗体最常用的方法之一。我们的数据表明,仅使用一个平台进行抗体验证可能会提供误导性信息,因此应该至少使用另一种方法来验证所获得的数据。