Liu Zun-Lei, Yuan Xing-Wei, Yan Li-Ping, Yang Lin-Lin, Cheng Jia-Hua
East China Sea Fisheries Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Fishery Sciences, Shanghai 200090 China.
Ying Yong Sheng Tai Xue Bao. 2013 Sep;24(9):2631-42.
By using the 2008-2010 investigation data about the body condition of small yellow croaker in the offshore waters of southern Yellow Sea (SYS), open waters of northern East China Sea (NECS), and offshore waters of middle East China Sea (MECS), this paper analyzed the spatial heterogeneity of body length-body mass of juvenile and adult small yellow croakers by the statistical approaches of mean regression model and quantile regression model. The results showed that the residual standard errors from the analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) and the linear mixed-effects model were similar, and those from the simple linear regression were the highest. For the juvenile small yellow croakers, their mean body mass in SYS and NECS estimated by the mixed-effects mean regression model was higher than the overall average mass across the three regions, while the mean body mass in MECS was below the overall average. For the adult small yellow croakers, their mean body mass in NECS was higher than the overall average, while the mean body mass in SYS and MECS was below the overall average. The results from quantile regression indicated the substantial differences in the allometric relationships of juvenile small yellow croakers between SYS, NECS, and MECS, with the estimated mean exponent of the allometric relationship in SYS being 2.85, and the interquartile range being from 2.63 to 2.96, which indicated the heterogeneity of body form. The results from ANCOVA showed that the allometric body length-body mass relationships were significantly different between the 25th and 75th percentile exponent values (F=6.38, df=1737, P<0.01) and the 25th percentile and median exponent values (F=2.35, df=1737, P=0.039). The relationship was marginally different between the median and 75th percentile exponent values (F=2.21, df=1737, P=0.051). The estimated body length-body mass exponent of adult small yellow croakers in SYS was 3.01 (10th and 95th percentiles = 2.77 and 3.1, respectively). The estimated body length-body mass relationships were significantly different from the lower and upper quantiles of the exponent (F=3.31, df=2793, P=0.01) and the median and upper quantiles (F=3.56, df=2793, P<0.01), while no significant difference was observed between the lower and median quantiles (F=0.98, df=2793, P=0.43).
利用2008 - 2010年关于小黄鱼在黄海南部近岸海域、东海北部开阔海域和东海南部近岸海域的身体状况调查数据,本文通过均值回归模型和分位数回归模型的统计方法分析了小黄鱼幼鱼和成鱼体长 - 体重的空间异质性。结果表明,协方差分析(ANCOVA)和线性混合效应模型分析得到的残差标准误差相似,而简单线性回归得到的残差标准误差最高。对于小黄鱼幼鱼,混合效应均值回归模型估计的黄海南部和东海北部的平均体重高于三个区域的总体平均体重,而东海南部的平均体重低于总体平均体重。对于小黄鱼成鱼,东海北部的平均体重高于总体平均体重,而黄海南部和东海南部的平均体重低于总体平均体重。分位数回归结果表明,黄海南部、东海北部和东海南部小黄鱼幼鱼的异速生长关系存在显著差异,黄海南部异速生长关系的估计平均指数为2.85,四分位间距为2.63至2.96,表明体型存在异质性。协方差分析结果表明,第25百分位数和第75百分位数指数值之间(F = 6.38,自由度 = 1737,P < 0.01)以及第25百分位数和中位数指数值之间(F = 2.35,自由度 = 1737,P = 0.039)的异速生长体长 - 体重关系存在显著差异。中位数和第75百分位数指数值之间的关系差异不显著(F = 2.21,自由度 = 1737,P = 0.051)。黄海南部小黄鱼成鱼的估计体长 - 体重指数为3.01(第10和第95百分位数分别为2.77和3.1)。估计的体长 - 体重关系与指数的下限和上限分位数之间(F = 3.31,自由度 = 2793,P = 0.01)以及中位数和上限分位数之间(F = 3.56,自由度 = 2793,P < 0.01)存在显著差异,而下限和中位数分位数之间未观察到显著差异(F = 0.98,自由度 = 2793,P = 0.43)。