Al-Khalili Sereen M, Coppoc Gordon L
J Vet Med Educ. 2014 Spring;41(1):68-76. doi: 10.3138/jvme.0613-082R.
The hypothesis for the research described in this article was that viewing an interactive two-dimensional (2D) or three-dimensional (3D) stereoscopic pre-laboratory video would improve efficiency and learning in the laboratory. A first-year DVM class was divided into 21 dissection teams of four students each. Primary variables were method of preparation (2D, 3D, or laboratory manual) and dissection region (thorax, abdomen, or pelvis). Teams were randomly assigned to a group (A, B, or C) in a crossover design experiment so that all students experienced each of the modes of preparation, but with different regions of the canine anatomy. All students were instructed to study normal course materials and the laboratory manual, the Guide, before coming to the laboratory session and to use them during the actual dissection as usual. Video groups were given a DVD with an interactive 10-12 minute video to view for the first 30 minutes of the laboratory session, while non-video groups were instructed to review the Guide. All groups were allowed 45 minutes to dissect the assigned section and find a list of assigned structures, after which all groups took a post-dissection quiz and attitudinal survey. The 2D groups performed better than the Guide groups (p=.028) on the post-dissection quiz, despite the fact that only a minority of the 2D-group students studied the Guide as instructed. There was no significant difference (p>.05) between 2D and 3D groups on the post-dissection quiz. Students preferred videos over the Guide.
本文所述研究的假设是,观看交互式二维(2D)或三维(3D)立体实验前视频将提高实验室中的效率和学习效果。一个一年级的兽医学班级被分成21个解剖小组,每组四名学生。主要变量是准备方法(2D、3D或实验室手册)和解剖区域(胸部、腹部或骨盆)。在交叉设计实验中,各小组被随机分配到一个组(A、B或C),以便所有学生都体验每种准备模式,但解剖犬类解剖学的不同区域。所有学生在参加实验室课程之前都被要求学习常规课程材料和实验室手册《指南》,并在实际解剖过程中照常使用。视频组在实验室课程的前30分钟观看一张包含10 - 12分钟交互式视频的DVD,而非视频组则被要求复习《指南》。所有小组有45分钟时间解剖指定部分并找到指定结构列表,之后所有小组都进行了解剖后测验和态度调查。在解剖后测验中,2D组的表现优于《指南》组(p = 0.028),尽管2D组中只有少数学生按照指示学习了《指南》。在解剖后测验中,2D组和3D组之间没有显著差异(p>0.05)。学生们更喜欢视频而不是《指南》。