Wang Keming, Sears Erika Davis, Shauver Melissa J, Chung Kevin C
17th Department of Plastic Surgery, Plastic Surgery Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, China.
Section of Plastic Surgery, The University of Michigan Health System, Ann Arbor, MI USA.
Hand (N Y). 2013 Jun;8(2):139-45. doi: 10.1007/s11552-012-9487-0.
The purpose of this study was to conduct a systematic review of outcomes of fingertip revision amputation for fingertip amputation injuries in the English-language literature to provide best evidence of functional outcomes.
A MEDLINE literature search was performed to identify studies that met the following criteria: (1) reported primary data; (2) included at least five cases of primary revision amputation treatment following digit amputation injury; (3) reported finger or thumb amputation at or distal to the distal interphalangeal (DIP) joint or interphalangeal (IP) joint, respectively; (4) presented at least one of the following outcomes: static two-point discrimination (2PD), cold intolerance, arc of motion (AOM) of metacarpophalangeal (MCP) joints, proximal interphalangeal joints (PIP), DIP joints, or return-to-work time.
Thirty-eight studies met the inclusion criteria. Twenty-seven studies reported 2PD, 20 studies reported cold intolerance, eight studies reported AOM, and 18 studies reported return-to-work time after revision amputation of fingertip injuries. The mean 2PD was 5.6 mm. On average, 24 % of patients experienced cold intolerance. AOM at the PIP joint was reported in four studies and averaged 94°. DIP joint AOM was presented in four studies and averaged 66°. Thumb MCP and IP joint AOM was presented in three and four studies, respectively. Mean thumb MCP joint AOM was 54° and that of the IP joint was 71°. The mean return-to-work time was 47 days.
On average, fingertip revision amputation can achieve almost normal sensibility and satisfactory motion and patients can expect to return to work on average approximately 7 weeks after surgery.
本研究旨在对英文文献中指尖离断伤的指尖修复性截肢结局进行系统评价,以提供功能结局的最佳证据。
进行MEDLINE文献检索,以确定符合以下标准的研究:(1)报告原始数据;(2)纳入至少5例手指离断伤后初次修复性截肢治疗的病例;(3)分别报告远端指间关节(DIP)或指间关节(IP)或其远端的手指或拇指离断;(4)呈现以下至少一项结局:静态两点辨别觉(2PD)、冷不耐受、掌指关节(MCP)、近端指间关节(PIP)、DIP关节的活动弧度(AOM)或重返工作时间。
38项研究符合纳入标准。27项研究报告了2PD,20项研究报告了冷不耐受,8项研究报告了AOM,18项研究报告了指尖损伤修复性截肢后的重返工作时间。平均2PD为5.6毫米。平均24%的患者有冷不耐受。4项研究报告了PIP关节的AOM,平均为94°。4项研究报告了DIP关节的AOM,平均为66°。分别有3项和4项研究报告了拇指MCP和IP关节的AOM。拇指MCP关节平均AOM为54°,IP关节为71°。平均重返工作时间为47天。
平均而言,指尖修复性截肢可实现几乎正常的感觉和满意的活动度,患者术后平均约7周有望重返工作岗位。