Behrmann-Godel J, Yohannes E
Limnological Institute, University of Konstanz,Mainaustrasse 252,D-78464,Konstanz,Germany.
J Helminthol. 2015 Mar;89(2):238-43. doi: 10.1017/S0022149X13000849. Epub 2014 Jan 22.
Previous studies of dietary isotope discrimination have led to the general expectation that a consumer will exhibit enriched stable isotope levels relative to its diet. Parasite-host systems are specific consumer-diet pairs in which the consumer (parasite) feeds exclusively on one dietary source: host tissue. However, the small numbers of studies previously carried out on isotopic discrimination in parasite-host (ΔXP-HT) systems have yielded controversial results, showing some parasites to be isotopically depleted relative to their food source, while others are enriched or in equilibrium with their hosts. Although the mechanism for these deviations from expectations remains to be understood, possible influences of specific feeding niche or selection for only a few nutritional components by the parasite are discussed. ΔXP-HT for multiple isotopes (δ13C, δ15N, δ34S) were measured in the pike tapeworm Triaenophorus nodulosus and two of its life-cycle fish hosts, perch Perca fluviatilis and pike Esox lucius, within which T. nodulosus occupies different feeding locations. Variability in the value of ΔXP-HT calculated for the parasite and its different hosts indicates an influence of feeding location on isotopic discrimination. In perch liver ΔXP-HT was relatively more negative for all three stable isotopes. In pike gut ΔXP-HT was more positive for δ13C, as expected in conventional consumer-diet systems. For parasites feeding on pike gut, however, the δ15N and δ34S isotope values were comparable with those of the host. We discuss potential causes of these deviations from expectations, including the effect of specific parasite feeding niches, and conclude that ΔXP-HT should be critically evaluated for trophic interactions between parasite and host before general patterns are assumed.
先前关于饮食同位素歧视的研究普遍认为,消费者体内的稳定同位素水平相对于其饮食会有所富集。寄生虫-宿主系统是特定的消费者-饮食对,其中消费者(寄生虫)仅以一种饮食来源为食:宿主组织。然而,先前对寄生虫-宿主(ΔXP-HT)系统中同位素歧视进行的少量研究得出了有争议的结果,一些寄生虫相对于其食物来源同位素贫化,而另一些则富集或与其宿主处于平衡状态。尽管这些与预期偏差的机制仍有待理解,但讨论了特定摄食生态位或寄生虫仅对少数营养成分进行选择的可能影响。在梭子绦虫Triaenophorus nodulosus及其两个生命周期的鱼类宿主河鲈Perca fluviatilis和梭子鱼Esox lucius中测量了多种同位素(δ13C、δ15N、δ34S)的ΔXP-HT,其中T. nodulosus占据不同的摄食位置。为寄生虫及其不同宿主计算的ΔXP-HT值的变化表明摄食位置对同位素歧视有影响。在河鲈肝脏中,所有三种稳定同位素的ΔXP-HT相对更负。在梭子鱼肠道中,δ13C的ΔXP-HT更正,这在传统的消费者-饮食系统中是预期的。然而,对于以梭子鱼肠道为食的寄生虫,δ15N和δ34S同位素值与宿主相当。我们讨论了这些与预期偏差的潜在原因,包括特定寄生虫摄食生态位的影响,并得出结论,在假定一般模式之前,应严格评估ΔXP-HT在寄生虫与宿主之间营养相互作用中的作用。