From the Division of Trauma, Department of Surgery, University of Tennessee Health Science Center, Memphis, Tennessee.
J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2014 Feb;76(2):279-83; discussion 284-5. doi: 10.1097/TA.0000000000000101.
Aggressive screening to diagnose blunt cerebrovascular injury (BCVI) results in early treatment, leading to improved outcomes and reduced stroke rates. While computed tomographic angiography (CTA) has been widely adopted for BCVI screening, evidence of its diagnostic sensitivity is marginal. Previous work from our institution using 32-channel multidetector CTA in 684 patients demonstrated an inadequate sensitivity of 51% (Ann Surg. 2011,253: 444-450). Digital subtraction angiography (DSA) continues to be the reference standard of diagnosis but has significant drawbacks of invasiveness and resource demands. There have been continued advances in CT technology, and this is the first report of an extensive experience with 64-channel multidetector CTA.
Patients screened for BCVI using CTA and DSA (reference) at a Level 1 trauma center during the 12-month period ending in May 2012 were identified. Results of CTA and DSA, complications, and strokes were retrospectively reviewed and compared.
A total of 594 patients met criteria for BCVI screening and underwent both CTA and DSA. One hundred twenty-eight patients (22% of those screened) had 163 injured vessels: 99 (61%) carotid artery injuries and 64 (39%) vertebral artery injuries. Sixty-four-channel CTA demonstrated an overall sensitivity per vessel of 68% and specificity of 92%. The 52 false-negative findings on CTA were composed of 34 carotid artery injuries and 18 vertebral artery injuries; 32 (62%) were Grade I injuries. Overall, positive predictive value was 36.2%, and negative predictive value was 97.5%. Six procedure-related complications (1%) occurred with DSA, including two iatrogenic dissections and one stroke.
Sixty-four-channel CTA demonstrated a significantly improved sensitivity of 68% versus the 51% previously reported for the 32-channel CTA (p = 0.0075). Sixty-two percent of the false-negative findings occurred with low-grade injuries. Considering complications, cost, and resource demand associated with DSA, this study suggests that 64-channel CTA may replace DSA as the primary screening tool for BCVI.
Diagnostic study, level III.
积极筛查以诊断钝性脑血管损伤(BCVI)可实现早期治疗,从而改善预后并降低中风发生率。虽然计算机断层血管造影(CTA)已广泛应用于 BCVI 筛查,但其实验证据的诊断敏感性仍存在争议。本机构此前使用 32 通道多排 CT 在 684 例患者中的研究表明,其敏感性仅为 51%(Ann Surg. 2011,253: 444-450)。数字减影血管造影(DSA)仍然是诊断的金标准,但具有侵袭性和资源需求的显著缺点。CT 技术不断取得进展,这是首次报道广泛应用 64 通道多排 CT 的经验。
在 2012 年 5 月结束的 12 个月期间,在一级创伤中心使用 CTA 和 DSA(参考标准)对 BCVI 进行筛查的患者被确定。回顾性分析并比较了 CTA 和 DSA 的结果、并发症和中风情况。
共有 594 例患者符合 BCVI 筛查标准,并同时接受了 CTA 和 DSA 检查。128 例患者(筛查患者的 22%)共有 163 条受损血管:99 条(61%)颈内动脉损伤和 64 条(39%)椎动脉损伤。64 排 CTA 对每条血管的总体敏感性为 68%,特异性为 92%。64 排 CTA 共发现 52 条假阴性结果,其中 34 条颈内动脉损伤和 18 条椎动脉损伤;32 条(62%)为 1 级损伤。总体而言,阳性预测值为 36.2%,阴性预测值为 97.5%。DSA 共发生 6 例与操作相关的并发症(1%),包括 2 例医源性夹层和 1 例中风。
与此前报道的 32 排 CTA 的 51%相比,64 排 CTA 的敏感性显著提高至 68%(p = 0.0075)。62%的假阴性结果发生在低级别损伤中。考虑到与 DSA 相关的并发症、成本和资源需求,本研究表明 64 排 CTA 可能替代 DSA 成为 BCVI 的主要筛查工具。
诊断研究,III 级。