Dholakia Yatin N, D'souza Desiree T B, Tolani Monica P, Chatterjee Anirvan, Mistry Nerges F
The Foundation for Medical Research, Mumbai, India.
Infect Dis Rep. 2012 Jan 18;4(1):e10. doi: 10.4081/idr.2012.e10. eCollection 2012 Jan 2.
The study was carried out in pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) patients from the local Tuberculosis control programme, Mumbai, India. It examined features of chest X-rays and their correlation with clinical parameters for possible application in suspected multidrug resistant TB (MDRTB) and to predict outcome in new and treatment failure PTB cases. X-ray features (infiltrate, cavitation, miliary shadows, pleural effusion, mediastinal lymphadenopathy and extent of lesions) were analyzed to identify associations with biological/clinical parameters through univariate and multivariate logistic regression. Failures demonstrated associations between extensive lesions and high glycosylated hemoglobin (GHb) levels (P=0.028) and male gender (P=0.03). An association was also detected between cavitation and MDR (P=0.048). In new cases, bilateral cavities were associated with MDR (P=0.018) and male gender (P=0.01), low body mass index with infiltrates (P=0.008), and smoking with cavitation (P=0.0238). Strains belonging to the Manu1 spoligotype were associated with mild lesions (P=0.002). Poor outcome showed borderline significance with extensive lesions at onset (P=0.053). Furthermore, amongst new cases, smoking, the Central Asian Strain (CAS) spoligotype and high GHb were associated with cavitation, whereas only CAS spoligotypes and high GHb were associated with extensive lesions. The study highlighted associations between certain clinical parameters and X-ray evidence which support the potential of X-rays to predict TB, MDRTB and poor outcome. The use of X-rays as an additional tool to shorten diagnostic delay and shortlist MDR suspects amongst nonresponders to TB treatment should be explored in a setting with limited resources coping with a high MDR case load such as Mumbai.
该研究在印度孟买当地结核病控制项目的肺结核(PTB)患者中开展。研究检查了胸部X光片的特征及其与临床参数的相关性,以便可能应用于疑似耐多药结核病(MDRTB),并预测新发病例和治疗失败的PTB病例的预后。通过单因素和多因素逻辑回归分析X光特征(浸润、空洞形成、粟粒状阴影、胸腔积液、纵隔淋巴结肿大和病变范围),以确定与生物学/临床参数之间的关联。治疗失败病例显示广泛病变与高糖化血红蛋白(GHb)水平(P = 0.028)以及男性性别(P = 0.03)之间存在关联。还检测到空洞形成与耐多药之间存在关联(P = 0.048)。在新发病例中,双侧空洞与耐多药(P = 0.018)和男性性别(P = 0.01)相关,低体重指数与浸润(P = 0.008)相关,吸烟与空洞形成(P = 0.0238)相关。属于Manu1 spoligotype的菌株与轻度病变相关(P = 0.002)。预后不良与发病时广泛病变具有临界显著性(P = 0.053)。此外,在新发病例中,吸烟、中亚菌株(CAS)spoligotype和高GHb与空洞形成相关,而只有CAS spoligotype和高GHb与广泛病变相关。该研究强调了某些临床参数与X光证据之间的关联,这支持了X光在预测结核病、耐多药结核病和不良预后方面的潜力。在像孟买这样资源有限且耐多药病例负担高的环境中,应探索将X光作为一种额外工具来缩短诊断延迟并在对结核病治疗无反应者中筛选出耐多药疑似病例。