Marshall Elizabeth, York Janet, Magruder Kathryn, Yeager Derik, Knapp Rebecca, De Santis Mark L, Burriss Louisa, Mauldin Mary, Sulkowski Stan, Pope Charlene, Jobes David A
Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC, USA,
Acad Psychiatry. 2014 Oct;38(5):566-74. doi: 10.1007/s40596-014-0039-5. Epub 2014 Feb 22.
Due to the gap in suicide-specific intervention training for mental health students and professionals, e-learning is one solution to improving provider skills in the Veterans Affairs (VA) health system. This study focused on the development and evaluation of an equivalent e-learning alternative to the Collaborative Assessment and Management of Suicidality (CAMS) in-person training approach at a Veteran Health Affairs medical center.
The study used a multicenter, randomized, cluster, and three group design. the development of e-CAMS was an iterative process and included pilot testing. Eligible and consenting mental health providers, who completed a CAMS pre-survey, were randomized. Provider satisfaction was assessed using the standard VA evaluation of training consisting of 20 items. Two post training focus groups, divided by learning conditions, were conducted to assess practice adoption using a protocol focused on experiences with training and delivery of CAMS.
A total of 215 providers in five sites were randomized to three conditions: 69 to e-learning, 70 to in-person, 76 to the control. The providers were primarily female, Caucasian, midlife providers. Based on frequency scores of satisfaction items, both learning groups rated the trainings positively. In focus groups representing divided by learning conditions, participants described positive reactions to CAMS training and similar individual and institutional barriers to full implementation of CAMS.
This is the first evaluation study of a suicide-specific e-learning training within the VA. The e-CAMS appears equivalent to the in-person CAMS in terms of provider satisfaction with training and practice adoption, consistent with other comparisons of training deliveries across specialty areas. Additional evaluation of provider confidence and adoption and patient outcomes is in progress. The e-CAMS has the potential to provide ongoing training for VA and military mental health providers and serve as a tutorial for psychiatrists in preparation for specialty boards.
由于心理健康专业学生和从业人员在自杀特异性干预培训方面存在差距,电子学习是提高退伍军人事务部(VA)医疗系统中医疗服务提供者技能的一种解决方案。本研究聚焦于在一家退伍军人健康事务医疗中心开发和评估一种与自杀协作评估与管理(CAMS)面对面培训方法等效的电子学习替代方案。
该研究采用多中心、随机、整群和三组设计。电子CAMS的开发是一个迭代过程,包括试点测试。完成CAMS预调查的符合条件并同意参与的心理健康服务提供者被随机分组。使用由20个项目组成的VA标准培训评估来评估服务提供者的满意度。根据学习条件分为两个培训后焦点小组,以使用侧重于CAMS培训和交付体验的方案来评估实践采用情况。
五个地点的215名服务提供者被随机分为三种情况:69人接受电子学习,70人接受面对面培训,76人作为对照组。这些服务提供者主要为中年白人女性。根据满意度项目的频率得分,两个学习组对培训的评价都很高。在按学习条件划分的焦点小组中,参与者描述了对CAMS培训的积极反应以及全面实施CAMS时类似的个人和机构障碍。
这是VA内部首次对自杀特异性电子学习培训进行的评估研究。就服务提供者对培训的满意度和实践采用情况而言,电子CAMS似乎与面对面的CAMS等效,这与跨专业领域的其他培训交付比较结果一致。目前正在对服务提供者的信心、采用情况和患者结局进行进一步评估。电子CAMS有潜力为VA和军事心理健康服务提供者提供持续培训,并作为精神科医生备考专科委员会的教程。