Jaremko Jacob L, Liu Lei, Winn Naomi J, Ellsworth Janet E, Lambert Robert G W
From the Department of Radiology and Diagnostic Imaging, and the Department of Pediatrics, W.C. Mackenzie Health Sciences Centre, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
J Rheumatol. 2014 May;41(5):963-70. doi: 10.3899/jrheum.131064. Epub 2014 Mar 15.
To compare the utility of radiography and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for the diagnosis of juvenile-onset spondyloarthritis in pediatric patients presenting with low back and/or sacroiliac (SI) pain of potentially inflammatory etiology.
Radiographs and MRI studies of the SI joints in 26 patients with juvenile spondyloarthritis (JSpA) and 35 controls were assessed independently by 2 radiologists, with discrepancies arbitrated by a third. Radiographs and MRI were blinded and read in separate batches in random order.
Erosion was common and was the most useful diagnostic feature on radiography [positive likelihood ratio (LR) = 3.5] and was especially diagnostic of SpA on MRI (LR = 6.7). Subchondral sclerosis was common but was the least specific feature for both modalities. Joint space narrowing had some utility on radiography (LR = 2.0) and MRI (LR = 2.7) but was uncommon and had poor reader reliability. Bone marrow edema (LR = 3.1) and subarticular fat infiltration (LR = 4.5), detectable only on MRI, were both useful features. Global diagnostic impression of MRI (LR = 9.4) had very high utility for the diagnosis of JSpA, exceeding radiography (LR = 4.4) because of superior specificity. In addition, global diagnosis of SpA is much more reliably made on MRI (κ = 0.80) compared to radiography (κ = 0.30).
Specificity and reliability of MRI of the SI joints are superior to radiography for the diagnosis of juvenile-onset SpA and, where available, MRI should replace radiography as the first line of investigation.
比较X线摄影和磁共振成像(MRI)在诊断有潜在炎性病因的小儿下背部和/或骶髂关节(SI)疼痛患者的幼年型脊柱关节炎中的效用。
2名放射科医生独立评估26例幼年型脊柱关节炎(JSpA)患者和35名对照者的SI关节X线片和MRI检查结果,如有分歧则由第三名医生仲裁。X线片和MRI检查结果均进行了盲法处理,并按随机顺序分批次读取。
侵蚀很常见,是X线摄影中最有用的诊断特征[阳性似然比(LR)= 3.5],在MRI上对脊柱关节炎的诊断尤为明显(LR = 6.7)。软骨下硬化很常见,但对两种检查方式来说都是特异性最低的特征。关节间隙变窄在X线摄影(LR = 2.0)和MRI(LR = 2.7)上有一定效用,但不常见且阅片者可靠性较差。骨髓水肿(LR = 3.1)和关节下脂肪浸润(LR = 4.5)仅在MRI上可检测到,都是有用的特征。MRI的整体诊断印象(LR = 9.4)对JSpA的诊断效用非常高,因其特异性更高,超过了X线摄影(LR = 4.4)。此外,与X线摄影(κ = 0.30)相比,MRI对脊柱关节炎的整体诊断更可靠(κ = 0.80)。
SI关节MRI在幼年型脊柱关节炎诊断中的特异性和可靠性优于X线摄影,在可行的情况下,MRI应取代X线摄影作为一线检查方法。