Gaillard D, Lespinasse P, Vanetti A
Hôpital Saint-Joseph, Paris, France.
Pacing Clin Electrophysiol. 1988 Nov;11(11 Pt 2):2142-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1540-8159.1988.tb06363.x.
Over a 17-year period (1970-1987) 75 patients, 3% of overall valvular surgery (VS) patients have been permanently paced at the time of VS (group 1), nine have been paced long after (group 2), 12 were already paced at the time of valve replacement (group 3), and 81 had a permanent pacing lead inserted during VS without further need for permanent pacing (group 4). Based on pre-, per- and post-operative clinical and electrocardiographic data we studied these four groups (GR). Aortic disease and especially calcified aortic stenosis (CAS) are the main valvular pathologies in all GR. The survival rate in GR 1 is lower than the survival rate of our overall VS PT5 due to older average ages and more severe cardiac conditions. In five patients GR 2 a myocardial pacing lead placed during VS was used long after for permanent stimulation. Patients in GR 3 were older than in other GR at the time of VS. The mortality was high in the patients operated on between 1973 and 1978 (average survived 3.5 years after pacing/2 years after VS) thus demonstrating the benefit of myocardial protection. For GR 4 the ratio of permanent lead implantation during VS was high in the late seventies (10%), it is now around 0.5%. In cases where the evolution of peroperative conduction disturbances is doubtful, it seems to us simpler to place a myocardial lead avoiding subsequent endocardial pacing if necessary, later, especially in patients with tricuspid disease.
在17年期间(1970 - 1987年),75例患者(占所有心脏瓣膜手术(VS)患者的3%)在进行VS时接受了永久性心脏起搏(第1组),9例在术后很久才进行起搏(第2组),12例在瓣膜置换时已进行起搏(第3组),81例在VS期间插入了永久性起搏导线但之后无需进一步永久性起搏(第4组)。基于术前、术中和术后的临床及心电图数据,我们对这四组进行了研究(组)。主动脉疾病尤其是钙化性主动脉瓣狭窄(CAS)是所有组中的主要瓣膜病变。第1组的生存率低于我们所有VS患者的总体生存率,原因是平均年龄较大且心脏状况更严重。在第2组的5例患者中,VS期间放置的心肌起搏导线在很久之后用于永久性刺激。第3组患者在VS时比其他组年龄更大。1973年至1978年期间接受手术的患者死亡率较高(起搏后平均存活3.5年/VS后2年),从而证明了心肌保护的益处。对于第4组,在七十年代后期VS期间永久性导线植入的比例较高(10%),现在约为0.5%。在术中传导障碍演变情况存疑的病例中,我们认为,如果有必要,放置心肌导线更为简单,这样可以避免之后进行心内膜起搏,尤其是对于患有三尖瓣疾病的患者。