Landy Stephen, McGinnis Judy
Wesley Headache Clinic, Memphis, Tennessee, USA.
Curr Ther Res Clin Exp. 2004 Jul;65(4):353-9. doi: 10.1016/j.curtheres.2004.06.003.
Early treatment with sumatriptan tablets (50 and 100 mg) has been shown to be effective in retrospective and prospective study designs. Despite the efficacy of sumatriptan 50 mg and early intervention, however, some patients continue not to respond completely to this dose. New evidence with a scientific basis for early intervention suggests that some patients may need to treat early to prevent the establishment of central sensitization. Also, patients cite complete pain relief as the most important attribute of a migraine medication.
The primary objective of this study was to determine the 2-hour efficacy of sumatriptan 100 mg in achieving complete pain relief in patients with a history of nonresponse to sumatriptan 50 mg in an early-intervention treatment paradigm. Secondary end points included complete pain relief at 4 hours, consistency of complete relief in at least 2 of 3 attacks, sustained complete relief over 24 hours, satisfaction with the 100-mg dose, and relief of associated symptoms.
This open-label, prospective study was conducted at the Wesley Headache Clinic (Memphis, Tennessee). Male and female patients between the ages of 18 and 65 years who fulfilled International Headache Society classification criteria for migraine, and who had a documented history of nonresponse to sumatriptan 50 mg at 2 hours after dosing when treating in the early, mild-pain phase in at least 2 of 3 migraine attacks were eligible for the study. Patients were instructed to receive one 100-mg sumatriptan tablet at the earliest sign of pain, while still mild, in 3 subsequent migraine attacks. After each treated attack, patients were to record a detailed diary entry.
Twenty patients (17 women, 3 men; mean age, 44 years) treated all 3 migraines during the early, mild-pain phase and completed the study. Of the 60 attacks treated, 48 (80%) were pain free at 2 hours, 56 (93%) were pain free at 4 hours, and 45 (75%) were pain free at 2 hours and continued to be pain free at 24 hours (sustained pain-free response). Sumatriptan 100 mg was well tolerated; none of the patients reported any adverse events.
In this study of migraineurs with a history of nonresponse to sumatriptan 50 mg at 2 hours after dosing in the early, mild-pain phase of migraine, increasing the dose of sumatriptan from 50 mg to 100 mg in the early-intervention paradigm, in most attacks complete pain relief was achieved for up to 24 hours. Because patients have indicated that becoming pain free was their therapeutic goal, based on the results of this study, physicians may want to consider increasing the dose of sumatriptan to 100 mg at the first sign of pain if the patient has consistently not responded to sumatriptan 50 mg in the early-intervention model.
在回顾性和前瞻性研究设计中,已证明早期使用舒马曲坦片(50毫克和100毫克)是有效的。然而,尽管50毫克舒马曲坦有效且进行了早期干预,但一些患者对该剂量仍未完全起效。有科学依据支持早期干预的新证据表明,一些患者可能需要早期治疗以防止中枢敏化的形成。此外,患者将完全缓解疼痛视为偏头痛药物最重要的特性。
本研究的主要目的是确定在早期干预治疗模式下,100毫克舒马曲坦在有50毫克舒马曲坦无反应史的患者中实现完全缓解疼痛的2小时疗效。次要终点包括4小时时的完全缓解疼痛、3次发作中至少2次完全缓解的一致性、24小时持续完全缓解、对100毫克剂量的满意度以及相关症状的缓解。
这项开放标签的前瞻性研究在卫斯理头痛诊所(田纳西州孟菲斯)进行。年龄在18至65岁之间、符合国际头痛协会偏头痛分类标准且在至少3次偏头痛发作中的2次早期轻度疼痛阶段给药后2小时有记录的50毫克舒马曲坦无反应史的男性和女性患者符合研究条件。患者被指示在随后3次偏头痛发作中,在疼痛仍为轻度的最早迹象时服用1片100毫克舒马曲坦片。每次治疗发作后,患者要记录详细的日记条目。
20名患者(17名女性,3名男性;平均年龄44岁)在早期轻度疼痛阶段治疗了所有3次偏头痛并完成了研究。在治疗的60次发作中,48次(80%)在2小时时无痛,56次(93%)在4小时时无痛,45次(75%)在2小时时无痛且在24小时时持续无痛(持续无痛反应)。100毫克舒马曲坦耐受性良好;没有患者报告任何不良事件。
在本研究中,对于在偏头痛早期轻度疼痛阶段给药后2小时有50毫克舒马曲坦无反应史的偏头痛患者,在早期干预模式下将舒马曲坦剂量从50毫克增加到100毫克,在大多数发作中可实现长达24小时的完全缓解疼痛。由于患者已表明无痛是他们的治疗目标,基于本研究结果,如果患者在早期干预模式下对50毫克舒马曲坦一直无反应,医生可能想在疼痛的最早迹象时考虑将舒马曲坦剂量增加到100毫克。