Wech Tobias, Shea Steven M, Barbot Julien, Vij Kamal, Pan Li, Lorenz Christine H, Patil Sunil
Center for Applied Medical Imaging and Computer Vision, Siemens Corporation, Corporate Technology, Baltimore, Maryland, USA; Institute of Radiology, University of Würzburg, Würzburg, Germany; Comprehensive Heart Failure Center, University of Würzburg, Würzburg, Germany.
J Magn Reson Imaging. 2014 Aug;40(2):490-5. doi: 10.1002/jmri.24374. Epub 2013 Oct 31.
To compare the spatial accuracy of three typical active tracking sequences using a new, unique phantom design.
Three different tracking sequences (Single Echo, Dual Echo and Hadamard Multiplexed) were compared with each other in a phantom study with respect to their positional accuracy. A custom-built phantom was constructed to conduct the experiments with precise framework conditions which facilitated sufficient measurement accuracy. An electrophysiology catheter incorporating four micro-coils was used as an interventional device. Tracking profiles were acquired in all three spatial dimensions and validated against the distances that were measured by a Vernier caliper in combination with a three-dimensional reference scan.
The Bland-Altman plots demonstrated that all three sequences show < 1.5 mm positional error. The measurement accuracy of Single Echo and Double Echo are prone to off-resonances, whereas Hadamard Encoding is immune to it.
The developed phantom enabled the performance of objective measurements of the accuracy of different active tracking sequences. The proposed setup allows for objectively contrasting different methods for interventional procedures.
使用一种全新的独特体模设计,比较三种典型主动跟踪序列的空间准确性。
在一项体模研究中,比较了三种不同的跟踪序列(单回波、双回波和哈达玛复用)的位置准确性。构建了一个定制体模,在精确的框架条件下进行实验,以确保足够的测量精度。将一根包含四个微线圈的电生理导管用作介入设备。在所有三个空间维度上获取跟踪轮廓,并与游标卡尺结合三维参考扫描测量的距离进行验证。
布兰德-奥特曼图表明,所有三个序列的位置误差均<1.5毫米。单回波和双回波的测量精度容易受到失谐的影响,而哈达玛编码则不受其影响。
所开发的体模能够对不同主动跟踪序列的准确性进行客观测量。所提出的设置允许对介入程序的不同方法进行客观对比。