Brenner R P, Reynolds C F, Ulrich R F
Department of Psychiatry, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, PA 15213.
Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol. 1989 Apr;72(4):298-304. doi: 10.1016/0013-4694(89)90065-5.
We report EEG findings in 33 elderly patients with mixed symptoms of depression and dementia, followed longitudinally to confirm diagnosis. Two groups of patients, dementia with depressive features (mixed-DEM, group I, n = 23) and patients with depressive pseudodementia (mixed-DEP, group II, n = 10), were defined. In addition, we also included, for comparison purposes, 35 patients with probable AD without depressive features (group III), 23 patients with major depression without cognitive impairment (group IV), and 61 healthy elderly controls (group V). We found significant group differences on waking EEGs between those mixed patients who did well after treatment for depression (depressive pseudodementia) compared to patients having dementia with secondary depression. The differences paralleled those between the 'pure' groups of demented and depressed patients. In patients with either depression or depressive pseudodementia, the EEG was usually normal or showed only mild abnormalities. In contrast, the majority of patients with either dementia or dementia with secondary depression had abnormal EEGs, with approximately one-third having moderate (or severe) abnormalities. Although the EEG was usually normal or only mildly abnormal in patients with pseudodementia or depression, these groups (II and IV) did show a significant slowing of the dominant posterior rhythm compared to controls. They also had a higher percentage of generalized abnormal EEGs than controls and this difference was significant between group IV (depression) and controls.
我们报告了33例患有抑郁和痴呆混合症状的老年患者的脑电图(EEG)检查结果,并进行了纵向随访以确诊。定义了两组患者,即伴有抑郁特征的痴呆(混合性痴呆,第一组,n = 23)和抑郁性假性痴呆患者(混合性抑郁,第二组,n = 10)。此外,为了进行比较,我们还纳入了35例无抑郁特征的可能患有阿尔茨海默病(AD)的患者(第三组)、23例无认知障碍的重度抑郁症患者(第四组)以及61名健康老年对照者(第五组)。我们发现,与患有继发性抑郁症的痴呆患者相比,那些在接受抑郁症治疗后情况良好的混合患者(抑郁性假性痴呆)在清醒脑电图上存在显著的组间差异。这些差异与痴呆患者和抑郁症患者的“纯”组之间的差异相似。在患有抑郁症或抑郁性假性痴呆的患者中,脑电图通常正常或仅显示轻度异常。相比之下,大多数患有痴呆或继发性抑郁症的痴呆患者脑电图异常,约三分之一有中度(或重度)异常。虽然假性痴呆或抑郁症患者的脑电图通常正常或仅轻度异常,但与对照组相比,这两组(第二组和第四组)的优势后节律明显减慢。他们的脑电图广泛异常的比例也高于对照组,并且第四组(抑郁症)与对照组之间的差异具有显著性。