Karbach Julia, Strobach Tilo, Schubert Torsten
a Department of Educational Science , Saarland University , Saarbrücken , Saarland , Germany.
Child Neuropsychol. 2015;21(3):285-301. doi: 10.1080/09297049.2014.899336. Epub 2014 Apr 3.
Working memory (WM) capacity is highly correlated with general cognitive ability and has proven to be an excellent predictor for academic success. Given that WM can be improved by training, our aim was to test whether WM training benefited academic abilities in elementary-school children. We examined 28 participants (mean age = 8.3 years, SD = 0.4) in a pretest-training-posttest-follow-up design. Over 14 training sessions, children either performed adaptive WM training (training group, n = 14) or nonadaptive low-level training (active control group, n = 14) on the same tasks. Pretest, posttest, and follow-up at 3 months after posttest included a neurocognitive test battery (WM, task switching, inhibition) and standardized tests for math and reading abilities. Adaptive WM training resulted in larger training gains than nonadaptive low-level training. The benefits induced by the adaptive training transferred to an untrained WM task and a standardized test for reading ability, but not to task switching, inhibition, or performance on a standardized math test. Transfer to the untrained WM task was maintained over 3 months. The analysis of individual differences revealed compensatory effects with larger gains in children with lower WM and reading scores at pretest. These training and transfer effects are discussed against the background of cognitive processing resulting from WM span training and the nature of the intervention.
工作记忆(WM)容量与一般认知能力高度相关,并且已被证明是学业成功的一个出色预测指标。鉴于工作记忆可通过训练得到改善,我们的目的是测试工作记忆训练是否对小学生的学业能力有益。我们采用前测-训练-后测-随访设计对28名参与者(平均年龄 = 8.3岁,标准差 = 0.4)进行了研究。在14次训练课程中,孩子们在相同任务上要么进行适应性工作记忆训练(训练组,n = 14),要么进行非适应性低水平训练(积极对照组,n = 14)。前测、后测以及后测3个月后的随访包括一套神经认知测试(工作记忆、任务转换、抑制)以及数学和阅读能力的标准化测试。适应性工作记忆训练比非适应性低水平训练带来的训练收益更大。适应性训练产生的益处转移到了一项未训练的工作记忆任务和一项阅读能力标准化测试中,但未转移到任务转换、抑制或数学标准化测试的表现上。向未训练的工作记忆任务的转移在3个月内得以维持。个体差异分析显示,在前测中工作记忆和阅读分数较低的儿童有更大的收益,存在补偿效应。我们结合工作记忆广度训练产生的认知加工背景和干预的性质对这些训练和转移效应进行了讨论。