Sawatsky Adam P, Zickmund Susan L, Berlacher Kathryn, Lesky Dan, Granieri Rosanne
J Grad Med Educ. 2014 Mar;6(1):32-8. doi: 10.4300/JGME-06-01-37.1.
The lecture remains the most common approach for didactic offerings in residency programs despite conflicting evidence about the effectiveness of this format.
The purpose of this study was to explore the perspectives of internal medicine residents toward conferences held in the lecture format.
The investigators invited internal medicine residents (N = 144) to participate in focus groups discussing their perspectives about noon conference lectures. The investigators used a semistructured guide to ask about motivations for attendance and effectiveness of noon conferences, transcribed the recordings, coded the discussions, and analyzed the results.
Seven focus groups with a total of 41 residents were held. This identified 4 major domains: (1) motivations for attendance; (2) appropriate content; (3) effective teaching methods; and (4) perspectives on active participation. Residents' motivations were categorized into external factors, including desire for a break and balance to their workload, and intrinsic attributes, including the learning opportunity, topic, and speaker. Appropriate content was described as clinically relevant, practical, and presenting a balance of evidence. Identified effective teaching methods included shorter teaching sessions focused on high-yield learning points structured around cases and questions. While active participation increases residents' perceived level of stress, the benefits of this format include increased attention and learning.
This study furthers our knowledge of the learning preferences of internal medicine residents within the changing environment of residency education and can be used in conjunction with principles of adult learning to reform how we deliver core medical knowledge.
尽管关于讲座这种形式的有效性存在相互矛盾的证据,但讲座仍是住院医师培训项目中最常见的教学方式。
本研究旨在探讨内科住院医师对讲座形式会议的看法。
研究人员邀请内科住院医师(N = 144)参加焦点小组,讨论他们对午间会议讲座的看法。研究人员使用半结构化指南询问参会动机和午间会议的有效性,转录录音,对讨论内容进行编码,并分析结果。
共举行了7个焦点小组,共有41名住院医师参加。确定了4个主要领域:(1)参会动机;(2)合适的内容;(3)有效的教学方法;(4)对积极参与的看法。住院医师的动机分为外部因素,包括渴望休息和平衡工作量,以及内在因素,包括学习机会、主题和演讲者。合适的内容被描述为与临床相关、实用且呈现证据平衡。确定的有效教学方法包括围绕病例和问题构建的、专注于高收益学习点的较短教学课程。虽然积极参与会增加住院医师的压力感,但这种形式的好处包括注意力和学习的提高。
本研究进一步加深了我们对住院医师培训教育不断变化的环境中内科住院医师学习偏好的了解,并可与成人学习原则结合使用,以改革我们传授核心医学知识的方式。