Pacheva Iliyana H, Milanov Ivan G, Ivanov Ivan S, Stefanov Rumen S
Department of Pediatrics and Medical Genetics, Medical University, Plovdiv
St. Naum Hospital of Neurology and Psychiatry, Medical University, Sofia
Folia Med (Plovdiv). 2013 Jul-Dec;55(3-4):46-55. doi: 10.2478/folmed-2013-0027.
To suggest diagnostic combinations of symptoms for migraine and tension type headache (TTH), and for differentiation of overlapping headache (classified as either migraine or TTH) through evaluation of the diagnostic value of combinations of characteristics included in the International Headache Society diagnostic criteria for migraine and TTH in children and adolescents.
The study comprised an epidemiological school-based study (412 of 1029 pupils with chronic/recurrent headache) and a clinical study conducted in the Pediatric Neurology Ward and outpatient clinic at Plovdiv Medical University Hospital (203 patients with chronic/recurrent headache). An inclusion criterion was at least two episodes of headache during the last year. Exclusion criteria were: headache occurring only during acute infections; withdrawal of informed consent. Headache was classified according to the International Classification of Headache Disorders 2nd edition (ICHD-II) The diagnostic value of all combinations of items in criteria C and D for migraine and TTH was measured by sensitivity, specificity, and odds ratio.
The combination "unilateral location, severe intensity, aggravation by physical activity" had 100% specificity for migraine. The combination "bilateral location, pressing-tightening quality, mild intensity, no aggravation by physical activity" had 100% specificity for TTH. The combinations: "migrainous location, severe intensity, aggravation by physical activity", "severe intensity, nausea", "pulsating quality, nausea", "pulsating quality, migrainous location, aggravation by physical activity" seemed to pose the greatest risk for developing migraine. These combinations--"no nausea, no photophobia", "bilateral location, mild intensity and either no aggravation by physical activity or pressing-tightening quality, or no nausea or no photophobia" increased the most the TTH risk. Using these combinations as additional criteria for overlapping headache we classified 50% of overlapping headache as TTH and 8.3% as migraine.
Some combinations of symptoms clarify the diagnosis of migraine and TTH. More than 50% of overlapping headache could be differentiated as TTH or MWA by the proposed combinations.
通过评估国际头痛协会儿童和青少年偏头痛及紧张型头痛(TTH)诊断标准中各项特征组合的诊断价值,提出偏头痛和紧张型头痛的症状诊断组合,以及用于鉴别重叠性头痛(归类为偏头痛或TTH)。
该研究包括一项基于学校的流行病学研究(1029名慢性/复发性头痛学生中的412名)和在普罗夫迪夫医科大学医院儿科神经科病房及门诊进行的一项临床研究(203名慢性/复发性头痛患者)。纳入标准为过去一年中至少有两次头痛发作。排除标准为:仅在急性感染期间出现的头痛;撤回知情同意书。头痛根据《国际头痛疾病分类》第2版(ICHD-II)进行分类。通过敏感性、特异性和比值比来衡量偏头痛和TTH标准C和D中所有项目组合的诊断价值。
“单侧位置、重度强度、体力活动可加重”这一组合对偏头痛的特异性为100%。“双侧位置、压迫性紧箍感性质、轻度强度、体力活动不加重”这一组合对TTH的特异性为100%。“偏头痛样位置、重度强度、体力活动可加重”“重度强度、恶心”“搏动性性质、恶心”“搏动性性质、偏头痛样位置、体力活动可加重”这些组合似乎是发生偏头痛的最大风险因素。“无恶心、无畏光”“双侧位置、轻度强度且体力活动不加重或有压迫性紧箍感性质,或无恶心或无畏光”这些组合最能增加TTH风险。将这些组合用作重叠性头痛的附加标准时,我们将50%的重叠性头痛归类为TTH,8.3%归类为偏头痛。
某些症状组合有助于明确偏头痛和TTH的诊断。通过所提出的组合,超过50%的重叠性头痛可区分为TTH或偏头痛。