van Zyl G S, Christofides N J
School of Public Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Int Nurs Rev. 2014 Jun;61(2):186-93. doi: 10.1111/inr.12101. Epub 2014 Apr 10.
In some countries, nursing's appeal as a profession is diminishing, partly due to poor press coverage and the media's portrayal of an over-loaded, poorly paid profession. The media is important for shaping public perceptions and raising policy issues. International Nurses Day gives nurses an opportunity to profile their critical contribution to quality health care.
To determine the influence of this commemorative day on press coverage about nursing by examining whether there was a difference in the proportion of South African press articles on nursing between January-April and May-June 2010.
A quantitative content analysis was conducted of all press articles mentioning 'nursing' or 'nurse/s' in the South African lay press from 1 January-31 June 2010. Articles were coded for theme, slant and prominence, and inter-coder reliability was assessed. Descriptive statistics with chi square or Fisher's exact tests were used to compare the two time periods.
We identified 242 articles in 95 publications. The month of May had almost double the press coverage of January. International Nurses Day articles were mainly positive, and appeared in May to June in weekly community publications rather than in daily national and regional newspapers. When they were excluded, most articles portrayed nursing negatively.
The 6-month period may not be representative of the entire year. Only the dominant topic was coded, which possibly influenced the analysis.
International Nurses Day positively influenced the extent and slant of press coverage. Efforts to sustain coverage beyond the event through strategic partnerships and media engagement should be strengthened.
The media's portrayal of nurses and nursing may influence the choice of nursing as a career. International Nurses Day is an opportunity to portray nursing positively. Media training may help nurses to advocate for their profession in the media.
在一些国家,护理作为一种职业的吸引力正在下降,部分原因是媒体报道不佳以及媒体将其描绘成一个负担过重、薪资微薄的职业。媒体对于塑造公众认知和提出政策问题很重要。国际护士节为护士们提供了一个机会来展示他们对优质医疗保健的关键贡献。
通过研究2010年1月至4月与5月至6月期间南非媒体关于护理的文章比例是否存在差异,来确定这个纪念日对媒体报道护理的影响。
对2010年1月1日至6月31日南非大众媒体中所有提及“护理”或“护士”的新闻文章进行定量内容分析。文章按照主题、倾向和突出程度进行编码,并评估编码员间的可靠性。使用卡方检验或费舍尔精确检验的描述性统计方法来比较这两个时间段。
我们在95种出版物中识别出242篇文章。5月的媒体报道几乎是1月的两倍。国际护士节相关文章主要是正面的,且在5月至6月出现在每周的社区出版物上,而非每日的全国性和地区性报纸。当排除这些文章后,大多数文章对护理的描述是负面的。
6个月的时间段可能不代表全年情况。仅对主要主题进行了编码,这可能影响了分析。
国际护士节对媒体报道的范围和倾向产生了积极影响。应加强通过战略伙伴关系和媒体参与在活动之后维持报道的努力。
媒体对护士和护理的描绘可能会影响人们选择护理作为职业。国际护士节是正面描绘护理的一个机会。媒体培训可能有助于护士在媒体上为其职业进行宣传。