Jo Hae W, Dalgorf Dustin M, Snidvongs Kornkiat, Sacks Raymond, Harvey Richard J
Applied Medical Research Center, St. Vincent's Hospital and University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia.
Am J Rhinol Allergy. 2014 Mar-Apr;28(2):169-71. doi: 10.2500/ajra.2014.28.4009.
Sinonasal care after endoscopic tumor resection aims to manage crusting, edema, mucus, and a healing cavity. High-volume irrigations have proved beneficial in this setting. The addition of corticosteroid to the irrigation is used for chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) in modifying the postsurgical inflammatory response; however, its effect in endoscopic sinonasal tumor resection is unknown. Saline alone versus combination saline and corticosteroid irrigations in postoperative nasal care of sinonasal tumor patients was assessed.
A retrospective cohort of patients postendoscopic endonasal tumor resection was assessed. Patients used 240 mL of saline or 240 mL of saline with 1 mg of betamethasone daily. Nasal symptom scores (NSSs) and the 22-item Sino-Nasal Outcome test (SNOT-22) was recorded 3 months postoperatively. An endoscopic score was made of the area undergoing secondary healing at 3 months by two blinded assessors.
Fifty-nine patients were assessed (aged 50.1 ± 18.26 years; 36% female subjects). The groups were similar in number (saline n = 31), treatment, and surgical characteristics. The endoscopic scores did not differ between the groups at 3 months. NSS was lower in the saline group (1.0 [interquartile range {IQR}, 3] versus 7.0 [IQR, 9]; p = 0.03) and, similarly, for SNOT-22 (0.24 [IQR, 1] versus 1.09 [IQR, 1]; p = 0.01) compared with the saline with steroid group.
Although corticosteroid irrigations have become routine for managing inflammatory sinus disease at our center, their use after tumor surgery does not appear to be warranted. The inflammatory healing process after tumor surgery differs from CRS inflammation and may explain the observed findings.
内镜肿瘤切除术后的鼻窦护理旨在处理结痂、水肿、黏液以及愈合中的术腔。大量冲洗已证实在这种情况下有益。在冲洗液中添加皮质类固醇用于慢性鼻窦炎(CRS)以改变术后炎症反应;然而,其在内镜鼻窦肿瘤切除中的效果尚不清楚。评估了单纯盐水冲洗与盐水和皮质类固醇联合冲洗在鼻窦肿瘤患者术后鼻腔护理中的效果。
对接受内镜鼻内肿瘤切除术后的患者进行回顾性队列研究。患者每天使用240毫升盐水或含1毫克倍他米松的240毫升盐水。术后3个月记录鼻症状评分(NSS)和22项鼻鼻窦结局测试(SNOT-22)。由两名盲法评估者对术后3个月二次愈合区域进行内镜评分。
共评估了59例患者(年龄50.1±18.26岁;36%为女性)。两组在数量(盐水组n = 31)、治疗和手术特征方面相似。3个月时两组的内镜评分无差异。与含类固醇盐水组相比,盐水组的NSS较低(1.0[四分位数间距{IQR},3]对7.0[IQR,9];p = 0.03),SNOT-22评分同样较低(0.24[IQR,1]对1.09[IQR,1];p = 0.01)。
尽管在我们中心,皮质类固醇冲洗已成为治疗炎性鼻窦疾病的常规方法,但在肿瘤手术后使用似乎并无必要。肿瘤手术后的炎症愈合过程与CRS炎症不同,这可能解释了观察到的结果。