Department of Environmental Health Engineering, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran.
Student Research Committee, Department of Environmental Health Engineering, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran.
Waste Manag. 2014 Jul;34(7):1251-6. doi: 10.1016/j.wasman.2014.03.010. Epub 2014 Apr 13.
From environmental viewpoint, the most important advantage of compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs) is reduction of green house gas emissions. But their significant disadvantage is disposal of spent lamps because of containing a few milligrams of toxic metals, especially mercury and lead. For a successful implementation of any waste management plan, availability of sufficient and accurate information on quantities and compositions of the generated waste and current management conditions is a fundamental prerequisite. In this study, CFLs were selected among 20 different brands in Iran. Content of heavy metals including mercury, lead, nickel, arsenic and chromium was determined by inductive coupled plasma (ICP). Two cities, Tehran and Tabriz, were selected for assessing the current waste management condition of CFLs. The study found that waste generation amount of CFLs in the country was about 159.80, 183.82 and 153.75 million per year in 2010, 2011 and 2012, respectively. Waste generation rate of CFLs in Iran was determined to be 2.05 per person in 2012. The average amount of mercury, lead, nickel, arsenic and chromium was 0.417, 2.33, 0.064, 0.056 and 0.012 mg per lamp, respectively. Currently, waste of CFLs is disposed by municipal waste stream in waste landfills. For improving the current conditions, we propose by considering the successful experience of extended producer responsibility (EPR) in other electronic waste management. The EPR program with advanced recycling fee (ARF) is implemented for collecting and then recycling CFLs. For encouraging consumers to take the spent CFLs back at the end of the products' useful life, a proportion of ARF (for example, 50%) can be refunded. On the other hand, the government and Environmental Protection Agency should support and encourage recycling companies of CFLs both technically and financially in the first place.
从环境角度来看,紧凑型荧光灯 (CFL) 的最重要优势是减少温室气体排放。但它们的一个显著缺点是处理废旧灯管,因为其中含有几毫克有毒金属,尤其是汞和铅。为了成功实施任何废物管理计划,获得关于产生废物的数量和成分以及当前管理条件的充足和准确信息是一个基本前提。在这项研究中,选择了伊朗 20 个不同品牌的 CFL 进行研究。使用电感耦合等离子体 (ICP) 测定重金属(包括汞、铅、镍、砷和铬)的含量。选择德黑兰和大不里士两个城市评估 CFL 的当前废物管理情况。研究发现,该国 2010 年、2011 年和 2012 年 CFL 的废物产生量分别约为 1.598 亿支、1.838 亿支和 1.537 亿支。2012 年,伊朗的 CFL 废物产生率为每人 2.05 支。每支灯中汞、铅、镍、砷和铬的平均含量分别为 0.417 毫克、2.33 毫克、0.064 毫克、0.056 毫克和 0.012 毫克。目前,CFL 废物通过市政废物流在垃圾填埋场处理。为了改善现状,我们建议借鉴其他电子废物管理中延伸生产者责任 (EPR) 的成功经验。实施 EPR 计划和先进的回收费用 (ARF),以收集和回收 CFL。为了鼓励消费者在产品使用寿命结束时将废旧 CFL 退回,可退还 ARF 的一部分(例如 50%)。另一方面,政府和环境保护局应首先在技术和财务上支持和鼓励 CFL 的回收公司。