Valeri B O, Gaspardo C M, Martinez F E, Linhares M B M
Department of Neuroscience and Behavior, Ribeirão Preto Medical School, University of São Paulo, Brazil.
Eur J Pain. 2014 Nov;18(10):1431-9. doi: 10.1002/ejp.508. Epub 2014 Apr 15.
Early and repeated experiences of pain may have long-term effects on vulnerable newborns hospitalized in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU), and neonatal pain responses may be affected by a variety of factors that neonates encounter. We tested the hypothesis that male preterm neonates exhibited greater pain sensitivity than females by assessing biobehavioural pain reactivity and recovery patterns to painful procedure.
Fifty-three infants born preterm and low birthweight who were admitted to NICU were observed during five phases (baseline, antisepsis, puncture, recovery-dressing and recovery-resting). Behavioural pain reactivity was measured using the Neonatal Facial Coding System (NFCS) and the Sleep-Wake States Scale (SWS). The heart rate (HR) was continuously recorded. All measures were assessed based on scores and magnitude of responses.
We found that male and female preterm neonates had similar patterns of behavioural pain reactivity and recovery; there were no statistical differences between groups in NFCS and SWS scores. However, male preterm infants presented higher HR immediately in the first minute of the puncture phase and also higher change in maximum HR between the baseline and puncture phases, than female preterm infants.
Although we found that male infants showed higher physiological reactivity to painful stimulus in some HR parameters than female infants, the evidences were not sufficient to confirm the influence of sex on biobehavioural response to pain in vulnerable neonates.
早期和反复的疼痛经历可能会对入住新生儿重症监护病房(NICU)的脆弱新生儿产生长期影响,新生儿的疼痛反应可能会受到新生儿所遇到的各种因素的影响。我们通过评估对疼痛操作的生物行为疼痛反应性和恢复模式,来检验男性早产儿比女性表现出更高疼痛敏感性这一假设。
对53名入住NICU的早产低体重儿在五个阶段(基线、消毒、穿刺、换药恢复和休息恢复)进行观察。使用新生儿面部编码系统(NFCS)和睡眠-觉醒状态量表(SWS)测量行为疼痛反应性。持续记录心率(HR)。所有测量均基于得分和反应幅度进行评估。
我们发现,男性和女性早产儿的行为疼痛反应性和恢复模式相似;两组在NFCS和SWS得分上无统计学差异。然而,与女性早产儿相比,男性早产儿在穿刺阶段的第一分钟心率立即更高,且基线和穿刺阶段之间的最大心率变化也更大。
尽管我们发现男性婴儿在某些心率参数上对疼痛刺激的生理反应性高于女性婴儿,但证据不足以证实性别对脆弱新生儿疼痛生物行为反应的影响。