Williams E M, Gordon A D, Richmond B G
Department of Biology, Buhl Hall, Chatham University, Woodland Road, Pittsburgh, PA 15232, USA.
Department of Anthropology, University at Albany - SUNY, 1400 Washington Avenue, Albany, NY 12222, USA.
J Hum Evol. 2014 Jul;72:52-63. doi: 10.1016/j.jhevol.2014.03.004. Epub 2014 Apr 18.
Multiple hominin species used and produced stone tools, and the archaeological record provides evidence that stone tool behaviors intensified among later members of the genus Homo. This intensification is widely thought to be the product of cognitive and anatomical adaptations that enabled later Homo taxa to produce stone tools more efficiently relative to earlier hominin species. This study builds upon recent investigations of the knapping motions of modern humans to test whether aspects of our upper limb anatomy contribute to accuracy and/or efficiency. Knapping kinematics were captured from eight experienced knappers using a Vicon motion capture system. Each subject produced a series of Oldowan bifacial choppers under two conditions: with normal wrist mobility and while wearing a brace that reduced wrist extension (∼30°-35°), simulating one aspect of the likely primitive hominin condition. Under normal conditions, subjects employed a variant of the proximal-to-distal joint sequence common to throwing activities: subjects initiated down-swing upper limb motion at the shoulder and proceeded distally, increasing peak linear and angular velocities from the shoulder to the elbow to the wrist. At the wrist, subjects utilized the 'dart-thrower's arc,' the most stable plane of radiocarpal motion, during which wrist extension is coupled with radial deviation and flexion with ulnar deviation. With an unrestrained wrist, subjects achieved significantly greater target accuracy, wrist angular velocities, and hand linear velocities compared with the braced condition. Additionally, the modern wrist's ability to reach high degrees of extension (≥28.5°) following strike may decrease risk of carpal and ligamentous damage caused by hyperextension. These results suggest that wrist extension in humans contributes significantly to stone tool-making performance.
多种古人类物种使用并制造石器,考古记录提供的证据表明,石器行为在人属的后期成员中有所强化。人们普遍认为,这种强化是认知和解剖学适应的产物,使得人属后期分类群相对于早期古人类物种能够更高效地制造石器。本研究基于最近对现代人类敲击动作的调查,以测试我们上肢解剖结构的某些方面是否有助于提高准确性和/或效率。使用Vicon动作捕捉系统从八名经验丰富的敲击者身上捕捉敲击运动学数据。每个受试者在两种条件下制作了一系列奥杜威双面砍砸器:一种是手腕正常活动,另一种是佩戴减少手腕伸展(约30°-35°)的支具,模拟早期古人类可能的状态。在正常情况下,受试者采用了投掷活动中常见的从近端到远端的关节顺序变体:受试者从肩部开始上肢向下摆动动作,并向远端推进,从肩部到肘部再到手腕,峰值线性和角速度逐渐增加。在手腕处,受试者利用“投镖者弧线”,即桡腕关节运动最稳定的平面,在此期间手腕伸展与桡侧偏斜相耦合,屈曲与尺侧偏斜相耦合。与佩戴支具的情况相比,在手腕不受限制的情况下,受试者的目标准确性、手腕角速度和手部线性速度明显更高。此外,现代手腕在敲击后达到高度伸展(≥28.5°)的能力可能会降低因过度伸展导致的腕骨和韧带损伤风险。这些结果表明,人类的手腕伸展对石器制作性能有显著贡献。