Juárez-Ramos V, Rubio J L, Delpero C, Mioni G, Stablum F, Gómez-Milán E
Granada University, Spain.
Granada University, Spain.
Conscious Cogn. 2014 May;26:133-44. doi: 10.1016/j.concog.2014.03.006. Epub 2014 Apr 16.
Several studies about schizophrenia have shown a cognitive bias named "Jumping to Conclusions" (JTC), defined as a decision made quickly on the basis of little evidence that occurs in these patients when performing probabilistic reasoning paradigms. The main objective of this study is to compare JTC bias and BADE (Bias Against Disconfirmatory Evidence) in patients with schizophrenia vs. participants with high/low schizotypy to understand the underlying mechanism of these cognitive biases. Probabilistic reasoning was assessed using a modified version of Drawing to Decision task. In addition to the traditional parameters of this task (Plausibility Rating (PR), Draws to Decision (DTD), BADE) we also calculated new parameters, overall accuracy and one named Feedback Sensitivity (FS) which lower scores shows greater use of feedback. The results of the study suggest a context effect: in the cued condition, there were not main differences between groups. In the uncued condition, we found higher JTC bias at stage 1 for patients. At the same time, PR at first stages related positively with Feedback Sensitivity and negatively with accuracy for patients and high schizotypy participants (high confidence is associated with worse performance and lower feedback use). BADE seems unrelated to JTC bias and FS. The results are discussed in terms of JTC like as a clinical bias and whether patients with schizophrenia are less able to use feedback.
多项关于精神分裂症的研究表明,存在一种名为“急于下结论”(JTC)的认知偏差,其定义为在执行概率推理范式时,这些患者基于很少的证据就迅速做出决定。本研究的主要目的是比较精神分裂症患者与高/低分裂型人格特质参与者的JTC偏差和反对证伪证据偏差(BADE),以了解这些认知偏差的潜在机制。使用改良版的“绘图决策任务”评估概率推理。除了该任务的传统参数(合理性评分(PR)、决策绘图次数(DTD)、BADE)外,我们还计算了新的参数,总体准确性和一个名为反馈敏感性(FS)的参数,较低的分数表明对反馈的使用更多。研究结果表明存在一种情境效应:在有提示的条件下,各组之间没有主要差异。在无提示的条件下,我们发现患者在第1阶段的JTC偏差更高。同时,对于患者和高分裂型人格特质参与者,第一阶段的PR与反馈敏感性呈正相关,与准确性呈负相关(高信心与较差的表现和较低的反馈使用相关)。BADE似乎与JTC偏差和FS无关。我们从将JTC视为一种临床偏差以及精神分裂症患者是否较不善于使用反馈的角度对结果进行了讨论。