Nikfarjam Mehrdad, Low Nicholas, Weinberg Laurence, Chia Ping Han, He Hong, Christophi Christopher
Department of Surgery, Austin Health, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
ANZ J Surg. 2014 Nov;84(11):823-6. doi: 10.1111/ans.12640. Epub 2014 Apr 22.
Total pancreatectomy (TP) is an operation that has long been associated with high morbidity and mortality, and rarely advocated for treatment of pancreatic tumours. Because of the improvements in diabetes management, there has been renewed interest in TP for treatment of pancreatic neoplasm, with a need to reassess outcomes.
Fifteen patients (9%) underwent TP in a single Australian high-volume tertiary institution between August 2005 and January 2012. Pancreaticoduodenectomy (PD) was performed in 150 patients during the same time period. Indications and peri-operative outcomes of patients were compared.
TP was performed for treatment of malignancy in 13 (87%) cases, for tumours involving the pancreatic neck. Complete tumour clearance achieved. Portal vein resections were more frequently required than in the PD group (5 (33%) versus 9 (6%); P = 0.004), as were blood transfusions (11 (73%) versus 28 (19%); P < 0.001), and median operative times were longer (10.5 versus 7.0 h; P < 0.001). Overall, complications were significantly greater in the TP group compared with the PD group (13 (87%) versus 86 (57%); P = 0.029), but the difference was mainly as a result of high grade I complications, in particular symptomatic hypoglycaemia (4 (27%) versus 0 (0%): P < 0.001) that could be easily managed. The overall lengths of stay and readmission rates were similar between groups.
TP should be considered in selective cases for treatment of pancreatic neoplasm if it allows complete clearance. The procedure does not appear to be associated with significant increases in serious complications compared with PD.
全胰切除术(TP)长期以来一直与高发病率和死亡率相关,很少被提倡用于治疗胰腺肿瘤。由于糖尿病管理的改善,人们对TP治疗胰腺肿瘤重新产生了兴趣,需要重新评估其疗效。
2005年8月至2012年1月期间,在澳大利亚一家大型三级医疗机构中,15例患者(9%)接受了TP手术。同期有150例患者接受了胰十二指肠切除术(PD)。比较了两组患者的手术指征和围手术期结果。
13例(87%)TP手术用于治疗恶性肿瘤,肿瘤累及胰颈部。实现了肿瘤的完全切除。与PD组相比,TP组更频繁地需要进行门静脉切除(5例(33%)对9例(6%);P = 0.004),输血情况也是如此(11例(73%)对28例(19%);P < 0.001),且中位手术时间更长(10.5小时对7.0小时;P < 0.001)。总体而言,TP组的并发症明显多于PD组(13例(87%)对86例(57%);P = 0.029),但差异主要是由于I级严重并发症,特别是症状性低血糖(4例(27%)对0例(0%):P < 0.001),而这种情况易于处理。两组之间的总住院时间和再入院率相似。
如果TP能实现肿瘤的完全切除,则应在选择性病例中考虑用于治疗胰腺肿瘤。与PD相比,该手术似乎不会导致严重并发症显著增加。