Ghaleb Sherein Salah, Elshabrawy Ekram Mohamad, Elkaradawy Magda Helal, Nemr Welson Nermeen
Faculty of Medicine, Benisuef University, Egypt; Faculty of Medicine, Cairo University, Egypt.
Faculty of Medicine, Benisuef University, Egypt.
J Forensic Leg Med. 2014 May;24:37-45. doi: 10.1016/j.jflm.2014.03.005. Epub 2014 Mar 29.
Torture is the most serious violation of a person's fundamental right to personal integrity and a pathological form of human interaction. In this study, the prevalence of torture in Cairo during the years 2009 & 2010 is 10.97% of the total number of cases examined at the medico legal authority of Egypt in Zenhom (11.29% in 2010 & 10.36% in 2009). The number of cases under this study is 367 (175 cases in 2009, 192 cases in 2010). Torture is more prevalent in the year 2010 than in the year 2009. The largest prevalence of torture was found in the area of south Cairo (120 cases; 32.7%) while the least was found in the area of west Cairo (50 cases; 13.6%). The victims included 336 males (91.6%) and 31 females (8.4%) with male to female ratio 10.8: 1. The most commonly affected age group in the studied victims was the age group of the third decade (171 cases; 46.6%) while the least was the age group above the sixth decade (6 cases; 1.6%). The most commonly affected site of injury was head & neck (243 cases; 66.2%) while the least was abdomen (17 cases; 4.6%). The most common type of injury was bruises (258 cases; 70.3%) while the least was electrocution (5 cases; 1.4%). Regarding the causal instrument, the most commonly used instrument was blunt object (333 cases; 90.7%) while the least was electric current (5 cases; 10%). Hitting with a stick leaving the characteristic shape of elongated abrasion & bruises was found in 35 cases (9.5%) and characteristic lesion of handcuff, which is blunt trauma wounds around wrists or ankles, was found in 68 cases (18.5%). There was one case of hair torture (0.3%) & 5 cases of sexual torture (1.5%). Permanent infirmity left in victims was positive in 24 cases (6.5%) and negative in 343 cases (93.5%) while deformity left in victims was positive in 10 cases (3%) and negative in 357 cases (97%). All permanent infirmity cases were male. Of the 24 cases of permanent infirmity, 83.3% were subjected to blunt trauma and 79.2% were injured in the upper limbs & this is statistically significant.
酷刑是对人的人身安全这一基本权利的最严重侵犯,也是一种病态的人际互动形式。在本研究中,2009年和2010年开罗酷刑的发生率占埃及宰赫农法医机构检查的总案件数的10.97%(2010年为11.29%,2009年为10.36%)。本研究的案件数为367起(2009年175起,2010年192起)。2010年酷刑的发生率高于2009年。酷刑发生率最高的是开罗南部地区(120起;32.7%),最低的是开罗西部地区(50起;13.6%)。受害者包括336名男性(91.6%)和31名女性(8.4%),男女比例为10.8:1。研究受害者中受影响最普遍的年龄组是三十多岁的年龄组(171起;46.6%),最少的是六十多岁以上的年龄组(6起;1.6%)。最常受影响的受伤部位是头部和颈部(243起;66.2%),最少的是腹部(17起;4.6%)。最常见的损伤类型是瘀伤(258起;70.3%),最少的是电击伤(5起;1.4%)。关于致伤工具,最常用的工具是钝器(333起;90.7%),最少的是电流(5起;1.0%)。发现35起(9.5%)用棍棒击打留下细长擦伤和瘀伤的特征形状,68起(18.5%)发现手铐的特征性损伤,即手腕或脚踝周围的钝器创伤伤口。有1起毛发酷刑案件(0.3%)和5起性酷刑案件(1.5%)。受害者留下永久性残疾的有24起(6.5%),无残疾的有343起(93.5%),受害者留下畸形的有10起(3%),无畸形的有357起(97%)。所有永久性残疾案件均为男性。在24起永久性残疾案件中,83.3%遭受钝器创伤,79.2%上肢受伤,这具有统计学意义。