Chinese Academy of Sciences, China.
Chinese Academy of Sciences, China; State University of New York at Buffalo, United States.
Accid Anal Prev. 2014 Sep;70:235-44. doi: 10.1016/j.aap.2013.12.015. Epub 2014 May 10.
To protect pedestrians, many countries give them priority at uncontrolled mid-block crosswalks or pedestrian crossings. However, the actual driver yielding rate is not always satisfactory (only 3.5% in this study). To increase the yielding rate, this study proposed eleven pedestrian gestures to inform drivers of their intent to cross. The gestures were evaluated based on the process of human interaction with environment. Four gestures were selected as candidates to test in field experiments based on scores for visibility, clarity, familiarity and courtesy (see illustration in Fig. 2): (1) right elbow bent with hands erect and palm facing left (R-bent-erect), (2) left elbow bent with hands level and palm facing left (L-bent-level), (3) left arm extended straight to left side with palm erect facing left (L-straight-erect), and (4) a 'T' gesture for "Time-out". In the experiment, confederate pedestrians waiting at the roadside displayed the gestures (baseline: no gesture) to 420 vehicles at 5 sites in Beijing, China. When pedestrians used the L-bent-level gesture, the vehicle yielding rate more than tripled of that in the baseline condition. The L-bent-level gesture also resulted in a significant decrease in driving with unchanged speed (63.5-38.8%) and had no significant side effects in terms of drivers' horn use or lane changing. The effects of such gestures in other contexts such as when pedestrians are in the crosswalk and when they are interacting with turning vehicles are discussed, together with the applications in training vulnerable pedestrian groups (children or elderly) and facilitating pedestrian detection by drivers.
为保护行人安全,许多国家会在无信号控制的路段或斑马线上给予行人优先通行权。然而,实际中司机的让行率并不总是令人满意(在本研究中仅为 3.5%)。为提高让行率,本研究提出了 11 种行人手势,以告知司机其穿越的意图。这些手势是根据人与环境的互动过程进行评估的。基于可视性、清晰度、熟悉度和礼貌性等得分,选择了四个手势作为候选手势,以在现场实验中进行测试(如图 2 所示):(1)右臂弯曲,双手垂直,掌心向左(R-bent-erect),(2)左臂弯曲,双手水平,掌心向左(L-bent-level),(3)左臂向左伸直,掌心垂直,掌心向左(L-straight-erect),(4)“T”手势表示“暂停”。在实验中,在北京市 5 个地点,420 辆汽车中,等待路边的行人会使用(基线:无手势)或不使用这 4 种手势。当行人使用 L-bent-level 手势时,车辆让行率比基线条件下增加了两倍多。与保持原速行驶(63.5-38.8%)相比,L-bent-level 手势还显著降低了车速,且对司机鸣笛或变道行为没有显著影响。还讨论了这些手势在其他情境下(例如行人在横道线上,以及与转弯车辆交互时)的效果,以及在培训弱势行人(儿童或老年人)和帮助司机检测行人方面的应用。