Knapp G
Methods Enzymol. 1989;180:192-212. doi: 10.1016/0076-6879(89)80102-8.
To make strong statements about possible tertiary structure or the relative stability of regions of secondary structure, the structure-probing experiments must go further than single-hit reactions. Some elements of the environment of the RNA molecule must be altered systematically. Knowledge of the effects of ions or other interacting factors on the activity or physical parameters (e.g., NMR and melting cooperativity) of the RNA help in experimental design. For example, the copious work on tRNA(Phe) compared the crystal and solution structures and allowed the direct correlation of Mg2+ stabilization of the tertiary structure of that molecule. Figure 3 demonstrates that pre-tRNA(Leu-3) responds to Mg2+ depletion in the same manner as detected by the appearance of highly sensitive RNase cleavage sites in the D and T psi C loops. Similar experiments titrating polyamine concentrations suggested that secondary structure was more efficiently stabilized by polyamines than by Mg2+. The variation of Mg2+ concentrations has been used to gain additional information about other RNA structures. Others have used protein-RNA interactions to approach the question of the functional structure of a RNA (for examples, see Ref. 3). Thus, the ideal parameters to choose would be those known to affect the function of the RNA. The variation of Mg2+ and polyamine concentrations would minimally suggest regions of greater or lesser secondary or tertiary structure stability.
为了对可能的三级结构或二级结构区域的相对稳定性做出有力论断,结构探测实验必须超越单次反应。RNA分子环境中的某些元素必须被系统地改变。了解离子或其他相互作用因子对RNA活性或物理参数(如核磁共振和熔解协同性)的影响有助于实验设计。例如,对苯丙氨酸转运RNA(tRNA(Phe))的大量研究比较了晶体结构和溶液结构,并实现了该分子三级结构的镁离子稳定性的直接关联。图3表明,前体亮氨酸转运RNA(pre-tRNA(Leu-3))对镁离子耗尽的反应,与在D环和TψC环中出现高敏感核糖核酸酶切割位点所检测到的反应方式相同。滴定多胺浓度的类似实验表明,多胺比镁离子更有效地稳定二级结构。镁离子浓度的变化已被用于获取有关其他RNA结构的更多信息。其他人则利用蛋白质-RNA相互作用来探讨RNA功能结构的问题(例如,见参考文献3)。因此,理想的选择参数应该是那些已知会影响RNA功能的参数。镁离子和多胺浓度的变化将最低限度地表明二级或三级结构稳定性较高或较低的区域。