Antshel K, Hier B, Fremont W, Faraone S V, Kates W
Department of Psychology, Syracuse University, Syracuse, New York, USA.
J Intellect Disabil Res. 2014 Oct;58(10):926-39. doi: 10.1111/jir.12134. Epub 2014 May 26.
The primary objective of the current study was to examine the childhood predictors of adolescent reading comprehension in velo-cardio-facial syndrome (VCFS). Although much research has focused on mathematics skills among individuals with VCFS, no studies have examined predictors of reading comprehension.
69 late adolescents with VCFS, 23 siblings of youth with VCFS and 30 community controls participated in a longitudinal research project and had repeat neuropsychological test batteries and psychiatric evaluations every 3 years. The Wechsler Individual Achievement Test-2nd edition (WIAT-II) Reading Comprehension subtest served as our primary outcome variable.
Consistent with previous research, children and adolescents with VCFS had mean reading comprehension scores on the WIAT-II, that were approximately two standard deviations below the mean and word reading scores approximately one standard deviation below the mean. A more novel finding is that relative to both control groups, individuals with VCFS demonstrated a longitudinal decline in reading comprehension abilities yet a slight increase in word reading abilities. In the combined control sample, WISC-III FSIQ, WIAT-II Word Reading, WISC-III Vocabulary and CVLT-C List A Trial 1 accounted for 75% of the variance in Time 3 WIAT-II Reading Comprehension scores. In the VCFS sample, WISC-III FSIQ, BASC-Teacher Aggression, CVLT-C Intrusions, Tower of London, Visual Span Backwards, WCST Non-perseverative Errors, WIAT-II Word Reading and WISC-III Freedom from Distractibility index accounted for 85% of the variance in Time 3 WIAT-II Reading Comprehension scores. A principal component analysis with promax rotation computed on the statistically significant Time 1 predictor variables in the VCFS sample resulted in three factors: Word reading decoding/Interference control, Self-Control/Self-Monitoring and Working Memory.
Childhood predictors of late adolescent reading comprehension in VCFS differ in some meaningful ways from predictors in the non-VCFS population. These results offer some guidance for how best to consider intervention efforts to improve reading comprehension in the VCFS population.
本研究的主要目的是探究 velocardiofacial 综合征(VCFS)患者青少年阅读理解能力的童年预测因素。尽管已有许多研究聚焦于 VCFS 患者的数学技能,但尚无研究考察阅读理解的预测因素。
69 名患有 VCFS 的青少年晚期患者、23 名 VCFS 患者的兄弟姐妹以及 30 名社区对照参与了一项纵向研究项目,每 3 年接受重复的神经心理测试组合和精神评估。韦氏个别成就测验第二版(WIAT-II)阅读理解子测验作为我们的主要结果变量。
与先前研究一致,患有 VCFS 的儿童和青少年在 WIAT-II 上的平均阅读理解分数比平均分低约两个标准差,单词阅读分数比平均分低约一个标准差。一个更新颖的发现是,相对于两个对照组,患有 VCFS 的个体阅读理解能力呈纵向下降,而单词阅读能力略有提高。在综合对照组样本中,韦氏儿童智力量表第三版(WISC-III)全量表智商(FSIQ)、WIAT-II 单词阅读、WISC-III 词汇和加利福尼亚语言学习测验第二版(CVLT-C)A 表第 1 次试验解释了第 3 次 WIAT-II 阅读理解分数中 75%的方差。在 VCFS 样本中,WISC-III FSIQ、BASC 教师评定攻击量表、CVLT-C 侵入错误、伦敦塔测验、倒背视觉广度、威斯康星卡片分类测验非持续性错误、WIAT-II 单词阅读和 WISC-III 注意力分散指数解释了第 3 次 WIAT-II 阅读理解分数中 85%的方差。对 VCFS 样本中具有统计学意义的第 1 次预测变量进行具有斜交旋转的主成分分析,得出三个因素:单词阅读解码/干扰控制、自我控制/自我监控和工作记忆。
VCFS 患者青少年晚期阅读理解能力的童年预测因素在某些有意义的方面与非 VCFS 人群的预测因素不同。这些结果为如何最好地考虑干预措施以提高 VCFS 人群的阅读理解能力提供了一些指导。