Phelan Dermot, Thavendiranathan Paaladinesh, Popovic Zoran, Collier Patrick, Griffin Brian, Thomas James D, Marwick Thomas H
Heart and Vascular Institute, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio.
University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Am Soc Echocardiogr. 2014 Aug;27(8):888-95. doi: 10.1016/j.echo.2014.04.015. Epub 2014 May 27.
The distinction of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) or cardiac amyloidosis (CA) from hypertensive heart disease may be difficult. The aim of this study was to determine the impact of parametric (polar) maps of regional longitudinal strain on identification of the etiology of mild to moderate left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH).
Twenty-four consecutive echocardiographic studies with mild to moderate LVH (eight with CA, eight with HCM, and eight with hypertensive heart disease) were selected on the basis of the availability of adequate images to assess longitudinal strain and absence of electrocardiographic criteria for low voltage or LVH or a pseudoinfarct pattern. Twenty level 3-trained readers provided the most likely of three diagnoses (CA, HCM, or hypertensive heart disease) and scored their confidence in making the diagnosis from two-dimensional images and diastolic parameters. A teaching exercise was provided on the interpretation of longitudinal strain in these cohorts, and interpretation was repeated with the addition of the strain polar map.
Baseline concordance among the readers was poor (κ = 0.28) and improved with the addition of strain data (κ = 0.57). Accuracy was improved with the addition of polar maps for the entire study cohort (P < .001), with 22% of cases reclassified correctly. The largest improvements in sensitivity (from 40% to 86%, P < .001), specificity (from 84% to 95%, P < .001), and accuracy (from 70% to 92%, P < .001) were seen for CA. The strain polar map significantly improved reader confidence in making the correct diagnosis overall (P < .001).
Regional variations in strain are easily recognizable, accurate, and reproducible means of differentiating causes of LVH. The detection of LVH etiology may be a useful clinical application for strain.
肥厚型心肌病(HCM)或心脏淀粉样变性(CA)与高血压性心脏病的鉴别可能存在困难。本研究的目的是确定区域纵向应变的参数(极坐标)图对轻至中度左心室肥厚(LVH)病因识别的影响。
基于有足够图像来评估纵向应变且不存在低电压、LVH或假性梗死图形的心电图标准,选择了24例连续的轻至中度LVH的超声心动图研究(8例CA、8例HCM和8例高血压性心脏病)。20名经过3级培训的读者给出三种诊断(CA、HCM或高血压性心脏病)中最可能的诊断,并对从二维图像和舒张参数做出诊断的信心进行评分。针对这些队列中的纵向应变解读进行了教学练习,并在加入应变极坐标图后重复进行解读。
读者之间的基线一致性较差(κ = 0.28),加入应变数据后有所改善(κ = 0.57)。加入极坐标图后,整个研究队列的准确性得到提高(P <.001),22%的病例被正确重新分类。CA的敏感性(从40%提高到86%,P <.001)、特异性(从84%提高到95%,P <.001)和准确性(从70%提高到92%,P <.001)改善最为显著。应变极坐标图显著提高了读者总体做出正确诊断的信心(P <.001)。
应变的区域差异是区分LVH病因的易于识别、准确且可重复的方法。LVH病因的检测可能是应变在临床上的一个有用应用。