Kim Harris Hyun-soo
Department of Sociology, Ewha Womans University, 52 Ewhayeodae-gil, Seodaemun-gu, Seoul, 120-750, Republic of Korea,
Int J Public Health. 2014 Oct;59(5):749-57. doi: 10.1007/s00038-014-0566-6. Epub 2014 Jun 1.
Much evidence suggests that social capital (e.g. networks, trust, organizational memberships) has a significant effect on self-reported health. Previous research, however, has focused primarily on Western countries. The current research seeks to remedy this problem by investigating the association between multiple social capital indicators and subjective health in a novel empirical setting.
The data come from the Comparative Values Survey of Islamic Countries (1999-2006) which consists of probabilistic samples from Muslim majority nations. Three-way multilevel analysis is used to examine the social determinants of health.
Statistical results from hierarchical linear modeling shows that frequent contact with strong and intermediate ties (i.e. family members and friends, respectively) is significant, while interaction with weak ties (coworkers) has no association. General trust and trust in the central government are also significantly related to subjective health, as is trust in religious authority, albeit in an inverse way.
This study calls for a more contingent view of the relationship between social capital and self-reported health. Future research needs to take this into consideration in hypothesizing and testing the potential health benefits of social capital.
大量证据表明,社会资本(如人际关系网络、信任、组织成员身份)对自我报告的健康状况有重大影响。然而,以往的研究主要集中在西方国家。当前的研究旨在通过在一个全新的实证环境中调查多种社会资本指标与主观健康之间的关联来弥补这一问题。
数据来自伊斯兰国家比较价值观调查(1999 - 2006年),该调查由来自穆斯林占多数国家的概率样本组成。采用三向多层次分析来检验健康的社会决定因素。
分层线性模型的统计结果表明,与强关系和中等关系(分别指家庭成员和朋友)的频繁接触具有显著意义,而与弱关系(同事)的互动则没有关联。一般信任和对中央政府的信任也与主观健康显著相关,对宗教权威的信任也是如此,尽管是以相反的方式。
本研究呼吁对社会资本与自我报告健康之间的关系采取更具权变的观点。未来的研究在假设和检验社会资本的潜在健康益处时需要考虑到这一点。