Beauchamp Guy
Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Montréal, Saint-Hyacinthe, Québec, Canada J2S 7C6
Proc Biol Sci. 2014 Jul 22;281(1787). doi: 10.1098/rspb.2014.0844.
Cooperative breeding is not common in birds but intriguingly over-represented in several families, suggesting that predisposing factors, similar ecological constraints or a combination of the two facilitate the evolution of this breeding strategy. The life-history hypothesis proposes that cooperative breeding is facilitated by high annual survival, which increases the local population and leads to a shortage of breeding opportunities. Clutch size in cooperative breeders is also expected to be smaller. An earlier comparative analysis in a small sample of birds supported the hypothesis but this conclusion has been controversial. Here, I extend the analysis to a larger, worldwide sample and take into account potential confounding factors that may affect estimates of a slow pace of life and clutch size. In a sample of 81 species pairs consisting of closely related cooperative and non-cooperative breeders, I did not find an association between maximum longevity and cooperative breeding, controlling for diet, body mass and sampling effort. However, in a smaller sample of 37 pairs, adult annual survival was indeed higher in the cooperative breeders, controlling for body mass. There was no association between clutch size and cooperative breeding in a sample of 93 pairs. The results support the facilitating effect of high annual survival on the evolution of cooperative breeding in birds but the effect on clutch size remains elusive.
合作繁殖在鸟类中并不常见,但有趣的是,在几个科中出现的比例过高,这表明易感因素、相似的生态限制或两者的结合促进了这种繁殖策略的进化。生活史假说提出,高年存活率促进了合作繁殖,这增加了当地种群数量并导致繁殖机会短缺。合作繁殖者的窝卵数预计也会较少。早期对一小部分鸟类的比较分析支持了这一假说,但这一结论一直存在争议。在这里,我将分析扩展到一个更大的全球样本,并考虑了可能影响对缓慢生活节奏和窝卵数估计的潜在混杂因素。在由密切相关的合作繁殖者和非合作繁殖者组成的81个物种对样本中,在控制饮食、体重和抽样努力的情况下,我没有发现最大寿命与合作繁殖之间的关联。然而,在一个较小的37对样本中,在控制体重的情况下,合作繁殖者的成年年存活率确实更高。在93对样本中,窝卵数与合作繁殖之间没有关联。结果支持了高年存活率对鸟类合作繁殖进化的促进作用,但对窝卵数的影响仍然难以捉摸。