European Medicines Agency, 7 Westferry Circus, Canary Wharf, London, E14 4HB, UK,
Paediatr Drugs. 2014 Aug;16(4):309-19. doi: 10.1007/s40272-014-0076-2.
Databases systematically collecting reports of suspected adverse drug reactions (ADRs) are a cornerstone of pharmacovigilance in that they provide on-going large-scale surveillance in the 'real-world' setting. Several studies have provided data on ADRs in children reported to national databases. EudraVigilance (EV) is the European Medicines Agency's (EMA) web-based system for reporting and evaluating suspected ADRs. Due to requirements on pharmaceutical companies to report ADRs that originate both inside and outside Europe, the data in EudraVigilance are global in nature. As such, it is potentially a rich source of information for paediatric pharmacovigilance.
The present study sought to provide a descriptive overview comparing ADRs involving children and adolescents aged less than 18 years with those involving adults reported to EudraVigilance across national boundaries. The results will serve as a baseline to explore whether lessons can be learned for paediatric pharmacovigilance.
All ADR reports received in EudraVigilance up to 13 June 2013 were analysed for overall numbers, age, gender, and geographic origin. Accurate age was determined when reported in valid format or calculated from the interval between date of birth and the reaction start date. The nature of the ADRs and the most frequently reported drug substances and drug event combinations were evaluated using Medical Dictionary for Regulatory Activities (MedDRA) 'preferred terms' (PTs) and 'system organ classes' (SOCs). The distribution over time of reported paediatric ADRs was also analysed.
As of 13 June 2013, EudraVigilance contained 3,291,593 spontaneous reports, for 75.9 % of which accurate age was determined; 11.2 % of these were paediatric reports. Paediatric ADRs were more common than those in adults under the MedDRA SOCs 'general and administration site', 'nervous system', 'skin and subcutaneous' and 'infections and infestations'. For children, the three most frequently reported MedDRA PTs, i.e. pyrexia, vomiting and convulsion (13, 6 and 4 % of reports, respectively), accounted for a greater proportion of reports than the corresponding top three in adults, i.e. nausea, dyspnoea and pyrexia (4, 4 and 3 % of reports, respectively). The 20 most reported active substances (12 of which are vaccines) together accounted for 52 % of paediatric reports as compared with 28 % of adult reports.
The present study applied a first-time approach to one of the largest databases worldwide of reported ADRs. It confirmed that reports of reactions in children were different to those in adults, not only in terms of reactions and drugs involved but also more concentrated around limited sets of reaction types and drugs. The possible causal association between a medicine or vaccine and the suspected ADR was not formally assessed in this study since the study analysed the characteristics of reported ADRs that were suspected and therefore not proven. However, the findings may help to identify pharmacovigilance activities that should be strengthened to reduce the burden of ADRs in children.
系统收集疑似药物不良反应(ADR)报告的数据库是药物警戒的基石,因为它们在“真实世界”环境中提供持续的大规模监测。有几项研究提供了向国家数据库报告的儿童 ADR 数据。EudraVigilance(EV)是欧洲药品管理局(EMA)用于报告和评估疑似 ADR 的基于网络的系统。由于制药公司需要报告在欧洲内外发生的 ADR,因此 EudraVigilance 中的数据具有全球性。因此,它可能是儿科药物警戒的丰富信息来源。
本研究旨在提供一个描述性概述,比较在跨越国界的 EudraVigilance 中报告的涉及儿童和青少年(年龄小于 18 岁)的 ADR 与涉及成年人的 ADR。研究结果将作为探索是否可以为儿科药物警戒提供经验的基线。
分析截至 2013 年 6 月 13 日 EudraVigilance 中收到的所有 ADR 报告的总数、年龄、性别和地理来源。当以有效格式报告时或从出生日期和反应开始日期之间的间隔计算时,确定准确的年龄。使用监管活动医学词典(MedDRA)“首选术语”(PT)和“系统器官类别”(SOC)评估 ADR 的性质以及最常报告的药物物质和药物事件组合。还分析了报告的儿科 ADR 的时间分布。
截至 2013 年 6 月 13 日,EudraVigilance 包含 3,291,593 份自发报告,其中 75.9%的报告准确年龄;这些报告中有 11.2%是儿科报告。与 MedDRA SOC“一般和给药部位”、“神经系统”、“皮肤和皮下组织”和“感染和寄生虫”相比,儿科 ADR 比成年人中更常见。对于儿童,报告中最常报告的三个 MedDRA PT 分别是发热、呕吐和惊厥(分别占报告的 13%、6%和 4%),占比高于成年人中相应的前三个,即恶心、呼吸困难和发热(分别占报告的 4%、4%和 3%)。前 20 种最报告的活性物质(其中 12 种是疫苗)共占儿科报告的 52%,而占成人报告的 28%。
本研究首次对全球最大的报告 ADR 数据库之一应用了一种方法。它证实,儿童反应与成人反应不仅在涉及的反应和药物方面有所不同,而且在有限的反应类型和药物方面也更加集中。由于本研究分析了疑似但未经证实的 ADR 报告的特征,因此未正式评估药物或疫苗与疑似 ADR 之间的可能因果关联。然而,这些发现可能有助于确定应加强药物警戒活动以减少儿童 ADR 负担。