Nakano Toshihide, Kado Hideaki, Tatewaki Hideki, Hinokiyama Kazuhiro, Machida Daisuke, Ebuoka Noriyoshi, Shoujima Takahiro, Ikarashi Jin
Department of Cardiovascular Surgery, Fukuoka Children's Hospital, Fukuoka, Japan.
Kyobu Geka. 2014 Apr;67(4):299-304.
We retrospectively reviewed our surgical results in patients with hypoplastic left heart syndrome( HLHS) to investigate the influence of surgical strategy on outcome.
Seventy-seven patients with classic HLHS were involved in this study. For the initial palliation, 23 patients underwent Norwood operation with modified Blalock-Taussig (BT) shunt, 23 patients underwent Norwood operation with right ventricle to pulmonary artery( RV-PA) shunt and 31 patients underwent bilateral pulmonary artery banding (BPAB). Surgical results, freedom from Fontan operation, hemodynamic data and incidence of complication after Fontan operation were compared between the 3 groups.
BPAB group had more preoperative risk factors than Norwood group. Total actuarial survival was 62.4% at 1 year and 58.2% at 3 and 5 years, and there was no difference between the groups. Freedom from Fontan completion was 59.4% at 3 years and 48.7% at 5 years without difference between the groups. The incidence of intervention for pulmonary artery stenosis was higher in Norwood with RV-PA shunt group(52.9%). Hemodynamic data obtained by cardiac catheterization were similar in the 3 groups, however, end-systolic elastance, which represents ventricular contractility, was lower in Norwood with RV-PA group.
Surgical results of Norwood with BT shunt and Norwood with RV-PA shunt were comparably satisfactory, however, there was possible concern of reduced ventricular contractility in RV-PA shunt group. BPAB was a effective and useful initial palliation in high risk cases.
我们回顾性分析了左心发育不全综合征(HLHS)患者的手术结果,以探讨手术策略对预后的影响。
本研究纳入了77例典型HLHS患者。对于初始姑息治疗,23例患者接受了改良布莱洛克-陶西格(BT)分流的诺伍德手术,23例患者接受了右心室至肺动脉(RV-PA)分流的诺伍德手术,31例患者接受了双侧肺动脉环扎术(BPAB)。比较了3组患者的手术结果、免于Fontan手术的情况、血流动力学数据以及Fontan手术后的并发症发生率。
BPAB组术前危险因素比诺伍德组更多。1年时的总精算生存率为62.4%,3年和5年时为58.2%,各组之间无差异。3年时免于完成Fontan手术的比例为59.4%,5年时为48.7%),各组之间无差异。RV-PA分流的诺伍德组肺动脉狭窄干预发生率更高(52.9%)。通过心导管检查获得的血流动力学数据在3组中相似,然而,代表心室收缩力的收缩末期弹性在RV-PA分流的诺伍德组中较低。
BT分流的诺伍德手术和RV-PA分流的诺伍德手术的手术结果同样令人满意,然而,RV-PA分流组可能存在心室收缩力降低的问题。BPAB是高危病例有效的初始姑息治疗方法。