Prescrire Int. 2014 May;23(149):121-4.
The standard opioids for relieving moderate to severe pain are: codeine as a step 2 analgesic and morphine for step 3. Tapentadol is an opioid similar to tramadol. An immediate-release form has been authorised in France for moderate to severe acute pain in adults and a sustained-release form for severe chronic pain in adults. It has been evaluated in comparative trials in several types of acute pain: pain following orthopaedic or gynaecological surgery or tooth extraction, and joint pain. These trials were principally designed to show its analgesic effect versus placebo.They did not establish the equianalgesic dose ratios of tapentadol to codeine, morphine or oxycodone. In chronic pain, one trial compared sustained-release tapentadol versus sustained-release morphine, but only unconvincing preliminary results are available.The results of other trials versus sustained-release oxycodone are unconvincing, because half of the patients were lost to follow-up. The known adverse effects of tapentadolare mainly those associated with all opioids, including neuropsychiatric disorders and addiction. Aggression and serotonin syndrome are possible reactions that require further investigation. Gastrointestinal disorders appeared less common with tapentadol than with oxycodone, but the data could well be biased due to the use of a relative overdose of oxycodone in the trials. In practice, the evaluation of tapentadol was not designed to show whether this drug represents a therapeutic advance. Its analgesic efficacy remains unclear, and it provokes the adverse effects common to all opioids.
作为第二阶梯镇痛药的可待因以及第三阶梯的吗啡。曲马多是一种与曲马朵类似的阿片类药物。速释剂型已在法国获批用于治疗成人中度至重度急性疼痛,缓释剂型用于治疗成人重度慢性疼痛。它已在多种急性疼痛的对比试验中进行了评估:骨科或妇科手术后疼痛、拔牙后疼痛以及关节疼痛。这些试验主要旨在证明其与安慰剂相比的镇痛效果。它们并未确定曲马多与可待因、吗啡或羟考酮的等效镇痛剂量比。在慢性疼痛方面,一项试验比较了缓释曲马多与缓释吗啡,但仅获得了不太令人信服的初步结果。与缓释羟考酮相比的其他试验结果也不令人信服,因为一半的患者失访了。曲马多已知的不良反应主要是与所有阿片类药物相关的那些,包括神经精神障碍和成瘾。攻击行为和5-羟色胺综合征是可能的反应,需要进一步研究。与羟考酮相比,曲马多引起的胃肠道疾病似乎较少见,但由于试验中使用了相对过量的羟考酮,数据很可能存在偏差。在实际应用中,对曲马多的评估并非旨在表明这种药物是否代表了一种治疗进展。其镇痛效果仍不明确,并且会引发所有阿片类药物共有的不良反应。