Verloop Willemien L, Vink Eva E, Spiering Wilko, Blankestijn Peter J, Doevendans Pieter A, Bots Michiel L, Vonken Evert-Jan, Voskuil Michiel
Department of Cardiology, University Medical Center, Utrecht, the Netherlands.
Eur J Clin Invest. 2014 Aug;44(8):728-35. doi: 10.1111/eci.12289.
In most previous studies investigating efficacy of renal denervation (RDN), patients with multiple renal arteries are generally excluded from treatment. This study was designed to determine the prevalence of multiple renal arteries in patients referred for RDN, to propose a classification for anatomical eligibility and to investigate the relation between the presence of multiple arteries and blood pressure (BP)-lowering effect.
Patients referred for RDN who underwent noninvasive imaging of the renal arteries before treatment were included in present analysis. Eligible patients were treated. Renal function and BP were evaluated 6 months after treatment.
Hundred and twenty-six patients referred for RDN were included in present analysis. Thirty-four per cent had multiple arteries. Sixty-nine patients underwent RDN. Office BP significantly reduced from 195 (± 26)/106 (± 14) mmHg to 165 (± 24)/95 (± 14) mmHg (P < 0·001). BP reduction in patients with multiple arteries which were all treated was comparable to patients with solitary arteries. However, patients with multiple which were not all treated showed a trend towards a less pronounced effect of RDN (β: 11·6, P = 0·11). The proposed classification appeared useful by identifying eligible anatomy. Renal function at 6 months did not differ from baseline in all subgroups.
Based on our results and the high prevalence of multiple arteries, it seems reasonable not to exclude patients with multiple renal arteries from RDN. Current analysis suggests that BP reduction may be less pronounced in patients with multiple renal arteries of whom not all arteries were treated.
在以往大多数研究肾去神经支配术(RDN)疗效的研究中,一般将有多条肾动脉的患者排除在治疗之外。本研究旨在确定接受RDN治疗的患者中多支肾动脉的患病率,提出解剖学适宜性的分类方法,并研究多支肾动脉的存在与血压降低效果之间的关系。
本分析纳入了接受RDN治疗且在治疗前接受了肾动脉无创成像的患者。符合条件的患者接受了治疗。治疗6个月后评估肾功能和血压。
本分析纳入了126例接受RDN治疗的患者。34%的患者有多支肾动脉。69例患者接受了RDN治疗。诊室血压从195(±26)/106(±14)mmHg显著降至165(±24)/95(±14)mmHg(P<0.001)。所有多支肾动脉均接受治疗的患者的血压降低情况与单支肾动脉患者相当。然而,并非所有多支肾动脉均接受治疗的患者显示出RDN效果不太显著的趋势(β:11.6,P=0.11)。所提出的分类方法通过识别适宜的解剖结构显得很有用。所有亚组6个月时的肾功能与基线相比无差异。
基于我们的研究结果以及多支肾动脉的高患病率,不将有多支肾动脉的患者排除在RDN治疗之外似乎是合理的。目前的分析表明,并非所有肾动脉均接受治疗的多支肾动脉患者的血压降低可能不太显著。