Shin Kyung Eun, Lee Kyung Soo, Yi Chin A, Chung Myung Jin, Shin Myung-Hee, Choi Yoon-Ho
Department of Radiology and Center for Imaging Science, Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Respirology. 2014 Aug;19(6):921-8. doi: 10.1111/resp.12337. Epub 2014 Jun 17.
Subcentimeter nodules without change in size during long-term follow-up period (for minimum 2 years) are assumed as benign lesions. However, the 2-year stability rule has not been fully verified so far and is still questionable. Thus, we aimed to retrospectively investigate long-term follow-up results for 2-year stable subcentimeter nodules at screening low-dose computed tomography (LDCT).
A total of 635 subjects having had follow-up LDCTs for the initial 2-year screening period and additional 3 years thereafter and having had non-calcified subcentimeter nodules were included. By using computed tomography (CT) nodule volumetry software, we measured interval changes in nodule volume.
A total of 1107 subcentimeter nodules (1037 solid, 70 ground-glass opacity nodules (GGNs)) were detected at baseline CT. Of 1037 solid nodules, 1032 showed no growth during the initial 2-year and 5-year follow-up period. Fifty-nine GGNs were stable for initial 2 years, but two (3.4%) were later proved as adenocarcinomas. Among five solid nodules that showed growth during the initial 2-year follow-up period, one (20%) proved to be an adenocarcinoma, whereas four (36.4%) of 11 GGNs that demonstrated growth were diagnosed as lung cancers.
All solid subcentimeter nodules having initial 2-year stability at screening LDCT can be considered benign because none shows growth at further follow-up CT. On the other hand, subcentimeter GGNs have more chance of growth than solid nodules and need further follow-up CT for more than 2 years.
在长期随访期(至少2年)内大小无变化的亚厘米级结节被认为是良性病变。然而,2年稳定性规则至今尚未得到充分验证,仍存在疑问。因此,我们旨在回顾性研究低剂量计算机断层扫描(LDCT)筛查时2年稳定的亚厘米级结节的长期随访结果。
纳入635名在最初2年筛查期及之后3年进行了随访LDCT且有非钙化亚厘米级结节的受试者。通过使用计算机断层扫描(CT)结节容积测量软件,我们测量了结节体积的间隔变化。
在基线CT检查时共检测到1107个亚厘米级结节(1037个实性结节,70个磨玻璃密度结节(GGN))。在1037个实性结节中,1032个在最初2年和5年随访期内无生长。59个GGN在最初2年稳定,但其中2个(3.4%)后来被证实为腺癌。在最初2年随访期内有生长的5个实性结节中,1个(20%)被证实为腺癌,而在11个有生长的GGN中,4个(36.4%)被诊断为肺癌。
在筛查LDCT时最初2年稳定的所有实性亚厘米级结节可被视为良性,因为在进一步的随访CT中均无生长。另一方面,亚厘米级GGN比实性结节有更多的生长机会,需要进行超过2年的进一步随访CT检查。