Salmela V R, Moisala M, Alho K
Institute of Behavioural Sciences, Division of Cognitive and Neuropsychology, University of Helsinki, FI-00014, Helsinki, Finland,
Atten Percept Psychophys. 2014 Oct;76(7):1962-74. doi: 10.3758/s13414-014-0714-3.
A common assumption in the working memory literature is that the visual and auditory modalities have separate and independent memory stores. Recent evidence on visual working memory has suggested that resources are shared between representations, and that the precision of representations sets the limit for memory performance. We tested whether memory resources are also shared across sensory modalities. Memory precision for two visual (spatial frequency and orientation) and two auditory (pitch and tone duration) features was measured separately for each feature and for all possible feature combinations. Thus, only the memory load was varied, from one to four features, while keeping the stimuli similar. In Experiment 1, two gratings and two tones-both containing two varying features-were presented simultaneously. In Experiment 2, two gratings and two tones-each containing only one varying feature-were presented sequentially. The memory precision (delayed discrimination threshold) for a single feature was close to the perceptual threshold. However, as the number of features to be remembered was increased, the discrimination thresholds increased more than twofold. Importantly, the decrease in memory precision did not depend on the modality of the other feature(s), or on whether the features were in the same or in separate objects. Hence, simultaneously storing one visual and one auditory feature had an effect on memory precision equal to those of simultaneously storing two visual or two auditory features. The results show that working memory is limited by the precision of the stored representations, and that working memory can be described as a resource pool that is shared across modalities.
工作记忆文献中的一个常见假设是,视觉和听觉通道具有独立的记忆存储。最近关于视觉工作记忆的证据表明,表征之间共享资源,并且表征的精度为记忆表现设定了限制。我们测试了记忆资源是否也在不同感官通道之间共享。分别针对两个视觉特征(空间频率和方向)和两个听觉特征(音高和音调持续时间)以及所有可能的特征组合测量了记忆精度。因此,仅改变记忆负荷,从一个特征到四个特征,同时保持刺激相似。在实验1中,同时呈现两个光栅和两个音调——两者都包含两个变化特征。在实验2中,依次呈现两个光栅和两个音调——每个仅包含一个变化特征。单个特征的记忆精度(延迟辨别阈值)接近感知阈值。然而,随着要记忆的特征数量增加,辨别阈值增加了两倍多。重要的是,记忆精度的下降并不取决于其他特征的通道,也不取决于这些特征是在同一物体还是不同物体中。因此,同时存储一个视觉特征和一个听觉特征对记忆精度的影响与同时存储两个视觉特征或两个听觉特征的影响相同。结果表明,工作记忆受存储表征精度的限制,并且工作记忆可以被描述为一个跨通道共享的资源池。