Laros-van Gorkom Britta Antonia Petra, Falaise Céline, Astermark Jan
Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Eur J Haematol Suppl. 2014 Aug;76:26-38. doi: 10.1111/ejh.12372.
The development of inhibitory antibodies to factor VIII (FVIII) or factor IX (FIX) in patients with haemophilia is a serious complication of treatment with coagulation factor concentrates. Antibodies develop in 10-15% of haemophilia A and in up to 5% of haemophilia B patients. Several strategies have been developed over the years to facilitate the eradication of inhibitors and reduce the cost. These include plasmapheresis and/or extracorporeal protein A absorption to remove the inhibitor from the plasma, and immunosuppression and/or immune modulation to suppress the production of inhibitory antibodies. Different immunosuppressive (IS) agents have been described with varying success. To evaluate the outcome of these agents, we performed a systematic literature review using the PubMed database. The total number of articles identified was 345; 299 papers were excluded leaving 46 papers to be included in the study. No randomised studies were identified, only case reports and case series. The most frequently used agents in the 46 case reports and cohort studies identified were cyclophosphamide and rituximab. All cases exposed to cyclophosphamide, rituximab and other IS agents had a complete success rate of 40-44%, 40-63% and 33-56%, respectively. However, the definition of success was not consistent among the studies. In conclusion, our review of the literature indicates that IS agents in combination with FVIII or FIX could be an option and may be cost-effective in many patients. The risk of adverse events seems to be relatively low. To fully explore the effect of IS agents, randomised studies are warranted.
血友病患者体内产生针对凝血因子 VIII(FVIII)或凝血因子 IX(FIX)的抑制性抗体是凝血因子浓缩物治疗的严重并发症。10% - 15%的甲型血友病患者以及高达5%的乙型血友病患者会产生抗体。多年来已开发出多种策略来促进抑制剂的清除并降低成本。这些策略包括血浆置换和/或体外蛋白A吸附以从血浆中去除抑制剂,以及免疫抑制和/或免疫调节以抑制抑制性抗体的产生。已描述了不同的免疫抑制(IS)药物,其成功率各不相同。为评估这些药物的疗效,我们使用PubMed数据库进行了系统的文献综述。确定的文章总数为345篇;排除299篇论文,留下46篇论文纳入研究。未发现随机研究,仅有病例报告和病例系列。在确定的46例病例报告和队列研究中最常用的药物是环磷酰胺和利妥昔单抗。所有接受环磷酰胺、利妥昔单抗和其他IS药物治疗的病例的完全成功率分别为40% - 44%、40% - 63%和33% - 56%。然而,各研究中成功的定义并不一致。总之,我们的文献综述表明,IS药物与FVIII或FIX联合使用可能是一种选择,并且在许多患者中可能具有成本效益。不良事件的风险似乎相对较低。为充分探索IS药物的效果,有必要进行随机研究。