Beattie R B, Dornan J C
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Queen's University of Belfast.
BMJ. 1989 Mar 11;298(6674):631-5. doi: 10.1136/bmj.298.6674.631.
To assess the usefulness of continuous wave Doppler ultrasonography as an antenatal screening tool for the detection of intrauterine growth retardation and fetal compromise 2097 singleton pregnancies were studied. Umbilical artery velocity waveforms were obtained at 28, 34, and 38 weeks of gestation, from which the pulsatility index, A/B ratio, and resistance parameter were calculated. No abnormal features or indices of neonatal outcome were adequately predicted. The most sensitive index for being delivered of a growth retarded infant (less than 5th centile birth weight for gestation) was an A/B ratio at 34 weeks (sensitivity 40%, specificity 84%). Other measures that show poor neonatal nutritional state (ponderal index, skinfold thickness, and ratio of mid-arm circumference to head circumference) were even less well predicted. Acute and chronic hypoxia as determined by Apgar score, pH in blood from the cord artery, and packed cell volume correlated poorly with umbilical artery waveform indices, and there was no obvious difference between the indices of those who subsequently required operative or instrumental delivery for fetal distress and those requiring no intervention. There were three unexplained stillbirths in the series, in each of which the fetus had shown waveform patterns that suggested increased peripheral resistance, though the technique did not appear to be useful for predicting the time of subsequent death. Screening for small for dates babies in a three stage programme was of no value regardless of the threshold or index chosen. Obstetricians should resist the temptation to introduce screening with Doppler ultrasonography until its proper role has been determined.
为评估连续波多普勒超声作为产前筛查工具检测胎儿宫内生长受限和胎儿窘迫的有效性,对2097例单胎妊娠进行了研究。在妊娠28、34和38周时获取脐动脉速度波形,计算搏动指数、A/B比值和阻力参数。未充分预测到新生儿结局的异常特征或指标。预测出生体重低于同孕周第5百分位数的生长受限婴儿出生的最敏感指标是34周时的A/B比值(敏感性40%,特异性84%)。其他显示新生儿营养状况差的指标(体重指数、皮褶厚度以及上臂围与头围之比)的预测效果更差。根据阿氏评分、脐动脉血pH值和红细胞压积确定的急性和慢性缺氧与脐动脉波形指标的相关性较差,随后因胎儿窘迫需要手术或器械助产的孕妇与无需干预的孕妇的指标之间无明显差异。该系列中有3例不明原因死产,每例胎儿的波形模式均提示外周阻力增加,尽管该技术似乎无法预测随后的死亡时间。无论选择何种阈值或指标,在三阶段方案中筛查小于孕周胎儿均无价值。在确定其恰当作用之前,产科医生应抵制引入多普勒超声筛查的诱惑。