Franke Melanie, Bröseler Frank, Tietmann Christina
Oral Health Prev Dent. 2015;13(2):163-8. doi: 10.3290/j.ohpd.a32340.
To evaluate how periodontitis patients perceive the outcome after long-term supportive therapy.
281 patients (150 women/131 men) with a mean age of 55 years (range: 45-86 years) were randomly selected and consecutively interviewed using a questionnaire designed for laypersons. All patients had shown high compliance with the recommended supportive periodontal therapy (SPT) for up to 16 years (mean observation period: 12.5 years). Statistical evaluation was performed using the 2-sided t-test.
A very high degree of confidence in the periodontal treatment (mean: 9.24, range 0-10) was found. Women noticed a higher positive impact on their social environment (P < 0.05). Patients who underwent SPT < 3 years showed a higher positive perception of treatment success than patients with SPT > 3 years (P < 0.01) and reported a greater impact on appearance (P < 0.01). Regenerative treatment demonstrated advantages over resective open flap debridement (OFD) procedures (P < 0.05) and scaling and root planing (SRP) (P < 0.05). However, treatment costs (P < 0.001) and time required (P < 0.01) for regenerative procedures were perceived as a burden. Periodontal treatment by a specialised team led to a significant reduction in the patients' complaints (P < 0.01). The SPT interval did not influence patients' perception of treatment success.
Systematic periodontal therapy with subsequent SPT met the patients' demand to preserve oral health. Regenerative procedures prompt the perception in patients of better remission of periodontitis symptoms. Further trials should investigate clinical results of periodontal therapy regarding patient expectations.
评估牙周炎患者对长期支持性治疗后疗效的认知情况。
随机选取281例患者(150名女性/131名男性),平均年龄55岁(范围:45 - 86岁),并使用专为非专业人士设计的问卷进行连续访谈。所有患者对推荐的支持性牙周治疗(SPT)表现出高度依从性,长达16年(平均观察期:12.5年)。采用双侧t检验进行统计学评估。
患者对牙周治疗的信心程度很高(平均值:9.24,范围0 - 10)。女性注意到牙周治疗对其社交环境有更高的积极影响(P < 0.05)。接受SPT少于3年的患者比接受SPT超过3年的患者对治疗成功的认知更为积极(P < 0.01),且对外观的影响更大(P < 0.01)。再生治疗相较于切除性开放瓣清创术(OFD)和龈下刮治及根面平整术(SRP)显示出优势(P < 0.05)。然而,再生治疗的成本(P < 0.001)和所需时间(P < 0.01)被视为负担。由专业团队进行牙周治疗可显著减少患者的不适(P < 0.01)。SPT间隔并未影响患者对治疗成功的认知。
系统性牙周治疗及后续的SPT满足了患者保持口腔健康的需求。再生治疗使患者更易感觉到牙周炎症状有更好的缓解。进一步的试验应针对患者期望研究牙周治疗的临床效果。