Ulmer Jeffery T, Harris Casey T, Steffensmeier Darrell
The Pennsylvania State University Department of Sociology and Crime, Law, and Justice.
University of Arkansas Department of Sociology and Criminal Justice.
Soc Sci Q. 2012 Sep 1;93(3):799-819. doi: 10.1111/j.1540-6237.2012.00868.x.
The objective of this study is to advance knowledge on racial/ethnic disparities in violence and the structural sources of those disparities. We do so by extending scarce and limited research exploring the relationship between race/ethnic gaps in disadvantage and differences in violent crime across groups.
Using census place-level data from California and New York, we construct White, Black, and Hispanic "gap" measures that take as a given the existence of disparities across race/ethnic groups in structural disadvantage and crime and subsequently utilize seemingly unrelated regression models to assess the extent to which gaps in disadvantage are predictive of gaps in homicide and index violence.
Our results suggest that (1) there is considerable heterogeneity in the size of White-Black, White-Hispanic, and Black-Hispanic gaps in structural disadvantage and crime and (2) that race/ethnic disparities in structural disadvantage, particularly poverty and female headship, are positively associated with race/ethnic gaps in homicide and index violence.
In light of recent scholarship on the racial invariance hypothesis and on the relationship between structural inequality and crime, the current study demonstrates that disparities in disadvantage, particularly family structure and poverty, are important in driving racial and ethnic disparities in crime.
本研究的目的是增进对暴力方面种族/族裔差异及其差异的结构性根源的认识。我们通过拓展稀缺且有限的研究来实现这一目标,该研究探讨弱势群体中种族/族裔差距与不同群体间暴力犯罪差异之间的关系。
利用加利福尼亚州和纽约州的人口普查地点层面数据,我们构建了白人、黑人和西班牙裔的“差距”指标,这些指标假定种族/族裔群体在结构性劣势和犯罪方面存在差异,随后运用看似不相关的回归模型来评估劣势差距在多大程度上可预测杀人罪和指数暴力方面的差距。
我们的结果表明:(1)在结构性劣势和犯罪方面,白人 - 黑人、白人 - 西班牙裔以及黑人 - 西班牙裔之间的差距大小存在相当大的异质性;(2)结构性劣势方面的种族/族裔差异,特别是贫困和女性当家,与杀人罪和指数暴力方面的种族/族裔差距呈正相关。
鉴于近期关于种族不变性假设以及结构性不平等与犯罪之间关系的学术研究,当前研究表明,劣势方面的差异,特别是家庭结构和贫困,在推动犯罪方面的种族和族裔差异方面具有重要意义。