Wallace Aaron S, Mantel Carsten, Mayers Gill, Mansoor Osman, Gindler Jacqueline S, Hyde Terri B
Global Immunization Division, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1600 Clifton Road NE, MS-A04, Atlanta, GA 30329, United States.
Immunizations, Vaccines and Biologicals Programme, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
Vaccine. 2014 Sep 15;32(41):5301-10. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2014.07.076. Epub 2014 Aug 1.
An increasing proportion of childhood immunization visits include administration of multiple injections. Future introduction of vaccines to protect against multiple diseases will further increase the number of injections at routine immunization childhood visits, particularly in developing countries that are still scaling up introductions. Parental and healthcare provider attitudes toward multiple injections may affect acceptance of recommended vaccines, and understanding these attitudes may help to inform critical decisions about vaccine introduction.
We conducted a systematic review of the literature to examine factors underlying reported parental and healthcare provider concerns and practices related to administration of multiple injections during childhood vaccination visits.
Forty-four articles were identified; 42 (95%) were from high income countries, including 27 (61%) from the USA. Providers and parents report concerns about multiple injections, which tend to increase with increasing numbers of injections. Common parental and provider concerns included apprehension about the pain experienced by the child, worry about potential side effects, and uncertainty about vaccine effectiveness. Multiple studies reported that a positive provider recommendation to the parent and a high level of concern about the severity of the target disease were significantly associated with parental acceptance of all injections. Providers often significantly overestimated parental concerns about multiple injections.
Providers may play a critical role in the decision for a child to receive all recommended injections. Their overestimation of parental concerns may lead them to postpone recommended vaccinations, which may result in extra visits and delayed vaccination. More research is needed on interventions to overcome provider and parental concern about multiple injections, particularly in developing countries.
儿童免疫接种就诊中,进行多次注射的比例日益增加。未来引入预防多种疾病的疫苗将进一步增加常规儿童免疫接种就诊时的注射次数,尤其是在仍在逐步扩大疫苗引入范围的发展中国家。家长和医疗服务提供者对多次注射的态度可能会影响对推荐疫苗的接受程度,了解这些态度可能有助于为疫苗引入的关键决策提供信息。
我们对文献进行了系统综述,以研究报道的家长和医疗服务提供者在儿童疫苗接种就诊时对多次注射的担忧及相关做法背后的因素。
共识别出44篇文章;42篇(95%)来自高收入国家,其中27篇(61%)来自美国。医疗服务提供者和家长均表示对多次注射存在担忧,且担忧程度往往随着注射次数的增加而上升。家长和医疗服务提供者常见的担忧包括对孩子经历疼痛的忧虑、对潜在副作用的担心以及对疫苗有效性的不确定。多项研究报告称,医疗服务提供者向家长给出积极推荐以及对目标疾病严重程度的高度关注与家长接受所有注射显著相关。医疗服务提供者常常显著高估家长对多次注射的担忧。
在决定儿童是否接受所有推荐注射方面,医疗服务提供者可能发挥关键作用。他们对家长担忧的高估可能导致他们推迟推荐的疫苗接种,这可能会导致额外就诊和疫苗接种延迟。需要开展更多研究,以探讨克服医疗服务提供者和家长对多次注射担忧的干预措施,尤其是在发展中国家。